d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Hockey >
Poll > Hockey Movie Vote
Prev15678Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 13,622
Joined: Nov 30 2011
Gold: 0.00
Nov 28 2014 12:46am
Quote (Darc-Deth @ Nov 28 2014 01:33am)
somebody gets it.


if i cant prove you wrong that way, ill prove you wrong at the way your looking at this dilemma.

do you know what an absolute truth is?

rock is harder than water. the number 10 is a value higher than the number 5.

you cannot prove that gladiator is absolutely better than troy.
Member
Posts: 38,401
Joined: Feb 3 2006
Gold: 26.26
Nov 28 2014 12:50am
Quote (pcgamingred @ Nov 28 2014 01:46am)
if i cant prove you wrong that way, ill prove you wrong at the way your looking at this dilemma.

do you know what an absolute truth is?

rock is harder than water. the number 10 is a value higher than the number 5.

you cannot prove that gladiator is absolutely better than troy.


i stopped reading your posts on page 4
Member
Posts: 29,222
Joined: Apr 13 2009
Gold: 1,400.00
Nov 28 2014 01:14am
Gladiator.

I'm with DD + LuLer on this one too.

You can judge movies and conclusively say one is better than the other if you base your judgement on everything (acting, cinematography, writing, plot,


You can also have an opinion on which you like more, which is not necessarily saying it is better or not. This is basing your judgement off a single criterion, entertainment.
An example used in this thread of this is colours. You can choose red or blue, they are based on your enjoyment of the colour.


Quote (pcgamingred @ Nov 27 2014 11:46pm)
if i cant prove you wrong that way, ill prove you wrong at the way your looking at this dilemma.

do you know what an absolute truth is?

rock is harder than water. the number 10 is a value higher than the number 5.

you cannot prove that gladiator is absolutely better than troy.


Of course you cannot prove this. If it was a universal truth it would have to be better in every single category every single time.
It is not, because on category is entertainment value, which is purely subjective.


Let's use hockey sticks for this.
You have a choice between all of the top of the line equipment from today or top of the line equipment from 1910.
Comparatively, the equipment from today is better in nearly every single category.
Sure, you could prefer to use the equipment from 1910, but that's based on your personal preference, not basing it on the integrity of the equipment itself.

Member
Posts: 27,518
Joined: May 10 2009
Gold: 13,891.00
Nov 28 2014 09:43am
Gladiator
Member
Posts: 50,655
Joined: Nov 18 2008
Gold: 4.00
Nov 28 2014 10:58am
Quote (Darc-Deth @ Nov 27 2014 03:02pm)
Whoever says troy is a retard.


/thread
Member
Posts: 30,151
Joined: Jul 12 2005
Gold: 160.14
Nov 28 2014 11:24am
I'll actually agree with pcgamingnerd here and say you can't really objectively say a movie is "better" than the other. With that said, if you believe Troy is a superior piece of work when compared to Gladiator, then you're either a teenager or I don't want to hang around you.
Member
Posts: 49,220
Joined: Oct 24 2003
Gold: 0.00
Nov 28 2014 11:46am
brave heart is better than both combined

Member
Posts: 13,622
Joined: Nov 30 2011
Gold: 0.00
Dec 3 2014 12:10am
the guy posted this in movies and tv shows as well lmao. and to my satisfaction, the same argument was had. granted, it sounded a lot more intellectual than ours yet yielded the same consensus.

http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=71690927&f=197
Member
Posts: 38,401
Joined: Feb 3 2006
Gold: 26.26
Dec 3 2014 12:17am
Quote (pcgamingred @ Dec 3 2014 01:10am)
the guy posted this in movies and tv shows as well lmao. and to my satisfaction, the same argument was had. granted, it sounded a lot more intellectual than ours yet yielded the same consensus.

http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=71690927&f=197


brings up old post to point out that he was wrong in 2 different threads.
Member
Posts: 60,938
Joined: Jun 28 2007
Gold: 69,837.29
Dec 3 2014 12:17am
Quote (pcgamingred @ Dec 3 2014 01:10am)
the guy posted this in movies and tv shows as well lmao. and to my satisfaction, the same argument was had. granted, it sounded a lot more intellectual than ours yet yielded the same consensus.

http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=71690927&f=197


congrats
Go Back To Hockey Topic List
Prev15678Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll