d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Hockey > Official Rumor Thread > Trades/draft Day/ufas
Prev13643653663673681445Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Views: 199393Replies: 14446Track Topic
Member
Posts: 26,437
Joined: Jan 20 2013
Gold: 982.86
#3651
Dec 16 2014 02:46pm
Quote (LuLer @ Dec 16 2014 04:44pm)
There's very few D-men that can play Phaneuf's role on the market. Teams don't wanna give up legit 5/6 D-men, forget top-4s.

If you trade away Phaneuf you'll have a tough time finding a deal for someone to take his spot, at least at a fair price.


Ph9 not a top 6 d man tho

E/ you mean in the league right? I dont think hes even close to that

This post was edited by Nearin on Dec 16 2014 02:46pm
Member
Posts: 39,227
Joined: Mar 1 2006
Gold: 12,140.00
#3652
Dec 16 2014 02:48pm
Quote (Nearin @ Dec 16 2014 01:46pm)
Ph9 not a top 6 d man tho

E/ you mean in the league right? I dont think hes even close to that


No, I mean 3rd pairing D-men, #5 or #6 :P not #5 or 6 overall in the league hehe.

No team has enough D-men that can play a regular NHL shift, everyone is looking for one or more.

This post was edited by LuLer on Dec 16 2014 02:48pm
Member
Posts: 63,625
Joined: Sep 27 2007
Gold: 103.00
#3653
Dec 16 2014 02:50pm
Quote (LuLer @ Dec 16 2014 03:26pm)
If Hall is going to get traded it should be for a package of futures or straight-up for stud D-man around the same age/worth. What they definitely shouldn't do is trade for a package of current NHLers.



If the Oilers are targeting Yandle, Oilers fans might as well kill themselves now.



OEL isn't moving.



RNH is more important than Hall IMO. RNH is a more complete player and a center is always going to be worth more if the players are in the same ballpark.




lol... If I was the Oilers I wouldn't trade just Hall for Kadri and Phaneuf let alone add a 1st... and I actually like both Kadri and Phaneuf.


Not sure how a small one way center is more of a complete player
Member
Posts: 39,227
Joined: Mar 1 2006
Gold: 12,140.00
#3654
Dec 16 2014 02:52pm
Quote (h4bs @ Dec 16 2014 01:50pm)
Not sure how a small one way center is more of a complete player


He's not small and he has a much more balanced 200 foot game.
Member
Posts: 26,437
Joined: Jan 20 2013
Gold: 982.86
#3655
Dec 16 2014 02:52pm
Quote (LuLer @ Dec 16 2014 04:48pm)
No, I mean 3rd pairing D-men, #5 or #6 :P not #5 or 6 overall in the league hehe.

No team has enough D-men that can play a regular NHL shift, everyone is looking for one or more.


Lol okay ya i was lolling at the idea that ph9 was in he top 6 d men lol

Im not saying replacing him is easy, but i think a bigmpart of the reason hes so hard to replace is his contract limits the value he is given trading him gets you leas trading chips to replace him than a good contract would have.

Member
Posts: 63,625
Joined: Sep 27 2007
Gold: 103.00
#3656
Dec 16 2014 02:55pm
Quote (LuLer @ Dec 16 2014 03:52pm)
He's not small and he has a much more balanced 200 foot game.


6'1 185lbs is small in the NHL. I'm 6 foot 180lbs lol I can't compete vs the bigger players
Member
Posts: 39,227
Joined: Mar 1 2006
Gold: 12,140.00
#3657
Dec 16 2014 02:59pm
Quote (h4bs @ Dec 16 2014 01:55pm)
6'1 185lbs is small in the NHL. I'm 6 foot 180lbs lol I can't compete vs the bigger players


He still looks like a little boy, he'll fill out. 6'1 is a fine height for a 1C.
Member
Posts: 63,625
Joined: Sep 27 2007
Gold: 103.00
#3658
Dec 16 2014 03:01pm
Quote (LuLer @ Dec 16 2014 03:59pm)
He still looks like a little boy, he'll fill out. 6'1 is a fine height for a 1C.


His height is ok, but he is scrawny AF nobody is scared of him and he will go flying if he tries to hit anyone. Not used on the PK, what's his face off %?

FO% under 50%, bad +/-

not sure what else he is good at other than being a playmaker

This post was edited by h4bs on Dec 16 2014 03:04pm
Member
Posts: 39,227
Joined: Mar 1 2006
Gold: 12,140.00
#3659
Dec 16 2014 03:04pm
Quote (h4bs @ Dec 16 2014 02:01pm)
His height is ok, but he is scrawny AF nobody is scared of him and he will go flying if he tries to hit anyone


Member
Posts: 45,148
Joined: Mar 8 2008
Gold: 795.90
#3660
Dec 16 2014 03:07pm
Quote (h4bs @ Dec 16 2014 04:55pm)
6'1 185lbs is small in the NHL. I'm 6 foot 180lbs lol I can't compete vs the bigger players


He was also 160 when drafted and 175 or something going into last season. For 6'1" players 185-195 is the sweet spot.

I also guarantee he's got a much denser build than you. I played with a guy who was 5'9" 165 of pure muscle. Hit like a fucking cannonball and if you underestimated how much you needed to brace, you're looking at the ceiling.
Go Back To Hockey Topic List
Prev13643653663673681445Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll

© 2003-2026 d2jsp  Contact