d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Hockey > Official St. Louis Blues Fan Thread
Prev1342343344345346351Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 27,555
Joined: Dec 19 2011
Gold: 8,732.50
Aug 23 2020 02:46pm
Quote (LuLer @ 23 Aug 2020 13:25)
Blues are obviously better than they showed, they didn't look right for 75% of the series.

And obviously Binnington was just awful so you didn't have much a chance to begin with. Gutsy call to go with Binnington again for game 6 but nobody can be too surprised because it's clear he's their "guy".


Their guy for last year for sure, not so much this season. He was just average, even Allen had better results than him other than much less starts. Especially in the playoffs, Allen played like an NHL goalie at least, where as binnington was playing like a echl goalie. I was hoping they start binnington for game 6, knew they had to go with their guy and lose together. Was Gucci Allen might e forced it game 7,and Idk if canucks woulda pulled through

This post was edited by Secksii on Aug 23 2020 02:48pm
Member
Posts: 39,217
Joined: Mar 1 2006
Gold: 12,140.00
Aug 23 2020 04:04pm
Quote (Secksii @ Aug 23 2020 01:46pm)
Their guy for last year for sure, not so much this season. He was just average, even Allen had better results than him other than much less starts. Especially in the playoffs, Allen played like an NHL goalie at least, where as binnington was playing like a echl goalie. I was hoping they start binnington for game 6, knew they had to go with their guy and lose together. Was Gucci Allen might e forced it game 7,and Idk if canucks woulda pulled through


Doesn't really matter what they did in the regular season.

Binnington won them over last year and Allen has been given umpteen chances and eventually failed every time. When push comes to shove, like it did in this series, they don't believe in Allen and nobody can blame them for that.
Member
Posts: 27,555
Joined: Dec 19 2011
Gold: 8,732.50
Aug 23 2020 05:53pm
Quote (LuLer @ 23 Aug 2020 15:04)
Doesn't really matter what they did in the regular season.

Binnington won them over last year and Allen has been given umpteen chances and eventually failed every time. When push comes to shove, like it did in this series, they don't believe in Allen and nobody can blame them for that.


If this was true, they wouldnt have even looked a binnington though lol. He failed them hard in the playoffs, not just against the Canucks. Allen had 1 bad game, not like binny 5+ times. If they completely ignored last year and the regular season, no one in their right mind would've played binnington, based on his performance.

I also agree that Allen was given a ton of chances in the past, and he proved that he's a good 1b at best. I'm just saying im glad they stayed with their guy to go down with, rather than choosing for their best odds of winning
Member
Posts: 52,835
Joined: Oct 9 2008
Gold: 250.00
Aug 24 2020 01:06pm
Quote (Secksii @ Aug 23 2020 06:53pm)
If this was true, they wouldnt have even looked a binnington though lol. He failed them hard in the playoffs, not just against the Canucks. Allen had 1 bad game, not like binny 5+ times. If they completely ignored last year and the regular season, no one in their right mind would've played binnington, based on his performance.

I also agree that Allen was given a ton of chances in the past, and he proved that he's a good 1b at best. I'm just saying im glad they stayed with their guy to go down with, rather than choosing for their best odds of winning


But I and most people disagree that allen gave them the best odds of winning. First off, binnington was the only blue who even tried during round robin. He made highlight reel saves just so we could lose 6-3 instead of 10-3 if allen was in.

Allen isn't the guy and he will never be the guy. He's most known for giving up a shitty goal at the worst time possible, not to mention the difference between he and markstrom in game 5 was the reason the blues lost. Allen was bad in game 5 and his spark had faded.

Id be much more pissed knowing we went with allen and lost than going with the guy who actually has the ability to carry, even if he played like shit in the series.

Maybe binnington is a one hit wonder. He wasn't bad last regulsr season and had a bad 3 games vs the canucks, but i don't think those 3 games are enough to judge. I do however think the last 5 yrs of Jake allen are enough to know what he is.
Member
Posts: 52,835
Joined: Oct 9 2008
Gold: 250.00
Aug 26 2020 10:47am
Tarasenko getting 3rd shoulder surgery....

Its safe to assume he may never be the same player if/when he can get back on the ice

Shitty, our 1 real gamebreaking offensive talent is having the prime of his career wrecked by shoulder issues.



Well we have cap room now, but a glaring need for a goal scorer
Member
Posts: 42,863
Joined: Oct 9 2010
Gold: 10.55
Member
Posts: 52,835
Joined: Oct 9 2008
Gold: 250.00
Oct 9 2020 01:49pm
Quote (Queefy @ Oct 9 2020 02:00pm)


Yea its rough

Army is a good GM but I think he's picking the wrong hill to die on when it comes to extensions to aging players. That hill should've been faulk or even schenn
Member
Posts: 52,835
Joined: Oct 9 2008
Gold: 250.00
Oct 9 2020 06:42pm
Fuckin torey Krug for 7yrs and 6.5mil. I dont get it. We had enough defenseman that even if we knew petro was gone, we didn't need anything there. Were very short at forward.

Add in the fact hes a lefty version of faulk, and consider me disappointed.

Ever since we won the cup, I feel like all of armstrongs big moves were wrong. The faulk extension, schenn extension, scandella extension, letting petro get to free agency, and then the desperation to sign a PP specialist to a deal not much less than petro


I can honestly see us as a non playoff team next year

The mess army created with faulk is killing us, because now he's trying to put a bandaid on a gaping wound and we're gonna be mediocre and capped out for years to come

This post was edited by 696969696969696969696969696969 on Oct 9 2020 06:54pm
Member
Posts: 52,835
Joined: Oct 9 2008
Gold: 250.00
Nov 7 2020 09:09pm
Hockey season yet?

This post was edited by 696969696969696969696969696969 on Nov 7 2020 09:15pm
Member
Posts: 52,835
Joined: Oct 9 2008
Gold: 250.00
Jan 8 2021 03:10pm
5 days til we put avs in their place, behind us in the standings
Go Back To Hockey Topic List
Prev1342343344345346351Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll