d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Hockey > 2021 Covid Season Game Day Thread
Prev1248249250251252372Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 39,227
Joined: Mar 1 2006
Gold: 12,140.00
Jun 2 2021 08:49pm
Quote (BareZ @ Jun 2 2021 07:48pm)
So you just care about injured players or intent to injure. Get a grip if you don’t think this was a terrible hit you’re a moron.


No idea what that means
Retired Moderator
Posts: 29,543
Joined: Aug 10 2006
Gold: 13,000.69
Trader: Trusted
Jun 2 2021 08:49pm
I personally think this was not a late hit nor a charge but a hit to the head. Also, considering the game was done with - That was very lame, show little to no professionalism. It's the playoff so that is to be expected, kid should have kept his head up too

This post was edited by Tosted on Jun 2 2021 08:50pm
Member
Posts: 6,218
Joined: Sep 13 2016
Gold: 2,657.74
Jun 2 2021 08:50pm
Quote (LuLer @ Jun 2 2021 07:44pm)
I can agree he had bad intentions. But most hits in the NHL come with bad intentions, you hit to hurt. How many hits are made in a game to separate a player from the puck? Most are made after the puck is already gone - "finishing hits".

If this falls under the new "principle point of contact" rule then fine, but other than that I think it's clean. No charge, not late.

Kid should still keep his head up. He could have been obliterated just the same if Schiefele went more through his chest and up. You don't have to get directly headshotted to get concussed.


the rules are clear that you can't zoom across the ice at top speed and lay down a hit for maximum damage. that's literally what the charging penalty is. the onus is on Scheifele to either make a play with the stick or letup, not for Evans to avoid the hit. it's like blaming a pedestrian for not looking both ways when he gets run over by a car that doesn't break.
Member
Posts: 13,380
Joined: Oct 12 2006
Gold: 0.00
Jun 2 2021 08:52pm
Quote (Tosted @ Jun 2 2021 10:49pm)
I personally think this was not a late hit nor a charge but a hit to the end. Also, considering the game was done with - That was very lame, show little to no professionalism. It's the playoff so that is to be expected, kid should have kept his head up too



He has the puck completely wrapped around before shief was 6fft of more way from him. It’s a completely uncalled off bullshit hit. It wouldn’t of stopped it either way. A follow through of that magnitude ? It’s ridiculous to say it was okay.
Member
Posts: 30,666
Joined: Dec 24 2006
Gold: 689.78
Jun 2 2021 08:53pm
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/E27KapXXMAIn0Rt?format=png&name=small

Can't link twitter images but you can see clearly Scheifele isn't even watching the puck; his stick could have easily stopped the goal. He's looking straight at Evans head.
Member
Posts: 39,227
Joined: Mar 1 2006
Gold: 12,140.00
Jun 2 2021 08:53pm
Quote (Hizkuntza @ Jun 2 2021 07:50pm)
the rules are clear that you can't zoom across the ice at top speed and lay down a hit for maximum damage. that's literally what the charging penalty is. the onus is on Scheifele to either make a play with the stick or letup, not for Evans to avoid the hit. it's like blaming a pedestrian for not looking both ways when he gets run over by a car that doesn't break.


The charging rule is about as muddy as it gets. The rulebook says "shall mean the actions of a player or goalkeeper who, as a result of distance traveled, shall violently check an opponent in any manner".

So what constitutes said distance? What if Schiefele started from his own blueline instead? The player could have still been concussed easily.

Every hit starts with the player skating from X distance.

And where the hell else was he going to skate? He's down 1 with 1 minute left in a playoff game and he's the first guy back with the other team looking to score an empty net goal lol
Retired Moderator
Posts: 29,543
Joined: Aug 10 2006
Gold: 13,000.69
Trader: Trusted
Jun 2 2021 08:54pm
Quote (BareZ @ Jun 2 2021 10:52pm)
He has the puck completely wrapped around before shief was 6fft of more way from him. It’s a completely uncalled off bullshit hit. It wouldn’t of stopped it either way. A follow through of that magnitude ? It’s ridiculous to say it was okay.


Nowhere close to saying it was okay, he deserves a suspension. The problem I have with it is not the fact that he is going to fast or if it was a late hit or not - The problem lies to the fact that his intent was to injure hence targeting the head.

This post was edited by Tosted on Jun 2 2021 08:54pm
Member
Posts: 14,319
Joined: Jun 19 2010
Gold: 7,271.48
Jun 2 2021 08:55pm
That sort of bullshit would be instant 20 games if this league was slightly serious about player safety
Member
Posts: 51,682
Joined: Jul 27 2007
Gold: 0.90
Jun 2 2021 08:55pm
Quote (Tosted @ 2 Jun 2021 22:54)
Nowhere close to saying it was okay, he deserves a suspension. The problem I have with it is not the fact that he is going to fast or if it was a late hit or not - The problem lies to the fact that his intent was to injure hence targeting the head.


I don't even know if it was a direct hit to the head, but that doesn't matter, it was still intent to injure
Retired Moderator
Posts: 29,543
Joined: Aug 10 2006
Gold: 13,000.69
Trader: Trusted
Jun 2 2021 08:56pm
Quote (Meatstick @ Jun 2 2021 10:55pm)
I don't even know if it was a direct hit to the head, but that doesn't matter, it was still intent to injure


Agreed
Go Back To Hockey Topic List
Prev1248249250251252372Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll