Quote (Subzer0isGG @ Jul 27 2022 06:53pm)
What's this mean "surplus value"? That's how much they being paid more than they should over length of contract based on "analytics"?
5. Darnell Nurse

Contract: $9.3M x eight years
Surplus Value: -$35.1M
Positive Value Probability: 22.7 percent
Basically, anything said in the Seth Jones blurb can be happily applied here for Darnell Nurse as well. He too has a roughly one-in-five chance of living up to his $9 million-plus deal where the biggest issue is contract length for a 27-year-old. Nurse also eats minutes and scores, but is probably not a true number one defender. The talent is there to be more, but the price tag is still too high.
Here’s the main difference with Nurse though: his last two seasons were strong enough to be a bit more optimistic about his future.
Early on in Nurse’s career, he struggled defensively and that was a continuous source of concern about his future as a high-end defender. Even his breakthrough year in 2021 was mostly driven by offence. Nurse was worth 1.9 wins that season, but there was plenty of reason to be skeptical he could keep that up. Combine that with The McDavid Factor likely boosting his numbers (something GSVA controls for to an extent) and there was good reason to be skeptical of Nurse’s new deal.
The 2021-22 season changed the math a bit. Nurse’s own scoring regressed, as did his offensive impact, but he cleaned up his defensive game to a substantial degree. Relative to teammates, he wasn’t giving up more chances against which is a departure from the entirety of his career. Overall, his effect was still negative. However, his offence more than made up for that. That’s a huge step and once again he played at a 1.9-win pace — not far off from the 2.1 wins he needs to be at to be worth his hefty cap hit.
The length of the deal and his age still make Nurse’s contract a very unlikely bet, but his recent trajectory leaves some room for optimism. In the short term, the deal may not be as painful as once thought. It’s worth noting too that Nurse’s best comp is Brent Burns so the best may be yet to come here (though, on the other hand, Brent Seabrook wasn’t far off either).