d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Hockey > Official Transactions Thread > Signings/trades/call Ups/etc
Prev1222922302231223222332487Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 42,979
Joined: Oct 9 2010
Gold: 21.69
Apr 12 2021 02:33pm
Quote (dragoneth @ Apr 12 2021 01:27pm)
so wait is kucherov healthy right now? he just said he will play for the playoffs like 100% surer


cause if hes healthy they are supposed to be forced to take him off LTIR i thought


he's been practicing but pretty sure its still non-contact, but thats all i know.

Quote (Secksii @ Apr 12 2021 01:02pm)
no way, mantha > vrana imo. swapping teams should do wonders for mantha

he's also locked up for only 5.7m for the next 3 seasons, whereas vrana is due for a raise

vrana also has beef with lavi's system

2nd is probably the cost to shred the cap

Quote (LuLer @ Apr 12 2021 01:05pm)
Even if you think Mantha > Vrana (debatable), he's not worth double Vrana.

I'd say Caps overpaid by at least one 2nd rounder.


Vrana and Mantha have almost identical numbres the past two years, mantha was on track to have a better year last year by about 0.11 points per game.
I think the swap of the two is pretty even, i expected to get like a 1st+ for him, so i think washington probably did overpay slightly, but if he plays well and helps them to a deep run/cup at any point in the next 3 years then it was easily worth it.
Member
Posts: 27,782
Joined: Dec 19 2011
Gold: 3,012.50
Apr 12 2021 02:38pm
Quote (VAS3CT0MY @ 12 Apr 2021 13:33)
he's been practicing but pretty sure its still non-contact, but thats all i know.



Vrana and Mantha have almost identical numbres the past two years, mantha was on track to have a better year last year by about 0.11 points per game.
I think the swap of the two is pretty even, i expected to get like a 1st+ for him, so i think washington probably did overpay slightly, but if he plays well and helps them to a deep run/cup at any point in the next 3 years then it was easily worth it.


caps definitely overpaid

if you look at the numbers without any context i guess they're even, but like you said mantha is 0.11 pts better still despite being in a rebuilding team at the bottom of standings.
You used just last 2 years, caps are #1 in the league this season and #2 for goals for as a team. Guess where your team was the last 2 years
Member
Posts: 42,979
Joined: Oct 9 2010
Gold: 21.69
Apr 12 2021 02:50pm
Quote (Secksii @ Apr 12 2021 01:38pm)
caps definitely overpaid

if you look at the numbers without any context i guess they're even, but like you said mantha is 0.11 pts better still despite being in a rebuilding team at the bottom of standings.
You used just last 2 years, caps are #1 in the league this season and #2 for goals for as a team. Guess where your team was the last 2 years


no doubt, but with mantha its an effort issue as well as a health issue, he's had plenty of opportunities to score more, but he doesnt keep his feet moving, and has the propensity to be lazy when trying to pick his spot and shoots right into the goalies chest.
I think he has the opportunity to produce more with the caps, but his numbers arent going to get all that much better if he isnt putting in the effort or staying healthy.

we'll see how it all goes down, but like i said, if mantha helps the caps to a cup or is atleast instrumental in a deep run at some point in the next few years it'll be worth the overpayment.
Member
Posts: 99,164
Joined: Nov 13 2004
Gold: 7,865.01
Apr 12 2021 03:17pm
Quote (Secksii @ Apr 12 2021 04:32pm)
yes he's healthy af, but u know they gotta say he's not 100% ready to go so they can wait til playoff start and put him out there when cap isn't an issue huehue


yeah thats bs the nhl should have a doctor check guys out every so often like once a month if they are on LTIR
the team can just pay off the team doctor to say hes not ready...thats so dumb

This post was edited by dragoneth on Apr 12 2021 03:17pm
Member
Posts: 28,247
Joined: May 27 2009
Gold: 18,101.00
Apr 12 2021 06:52pm
Quote (Secksii @ Apr 12 2021 01:38pm)
caps definitely overpaid

if you look at the numbers without any context i guess they're even, but like you said mantha is 0.11 pts better still despite being in a rebuilding team at the bottom of standings.
You used just last 2 years, caps are #1 in the league this season and #2 for goals for as a team. Guess where your team was the last 2 years


On the flip side Mantha had plenty of chances to shine on a weaker team.

Vrana was always behind a bunch of other players on the depth chart so he got less minutes and offensive opportunity.
Member
Posts: 28,247
Joined: May 27 2009
Gold: 18,101.00
Apr 12 2021 06:54pm
Quote (dragoneth @ Apr 12 2021 02:17pm)
yeah thats bs the nhl should have a doctor check guys out every so often like once a month if they are on LTIR
the team can just pay off the team doctor to say hes not ready...thats so dumb


It is an absolute sham.

Tampa has a stacked team due to cap exploitation.

They were able to keep players they should have never been able to afford and they loaded up at the deadline as well.

They should be punished for circumvention.
Member
Posts: 27,782
Joined: Dec 19 2011
Gold: 3,012.50
Apr 12 2021 10:22pm
Quote (Killingyouall @ 12 Apr 2021 17:52)
On the flip side Mantha had plenty of chances to shine on a weaker team.

Vrana was always behind a bunch of other players on the depth chart so he got less minutes and offensive opportunity.


Yeah we get to see how they both do, Vrana finally gets his chance to play more. Mantha reaps the benefit of playing more chill and potentially cherry picked minutes due to depth

Vrana got his fair share of chances and made the most of it playing with nearly ppg centers. Other teams are still focused to put out their best against Ovechkin.

Vrana had the luxury to be deployed 70% in the ozone this season and he averaged only 14 min on the ice. I'd say that's a very good offensive opportunity despite sounding like he's sheltered. (opposed to mantha at 50% dzone/ozone) Lavi and coaches love the way Vrana plays with the puck, but not so much away from the puck as he has similar problems as mantha's inconsistent effort level, and plays perimeter rather than battling for the puck. His ice time should increase in Detroit, playing top minutes with Larkin, but it also means that the other teams will put their best to focus shutting him down as well.

If mantha was scoring at a slightly higher rate than Vrana on a weaker team with his lack of effort, he should still theoritcally score more on a team that scores a lot (50goals more as of today) regardless of his effort level. So if mantha puts in the effort, it would be even more beneficial to him
Member
Posts: 27,782
Joined: Dec 19 2011
Gold: 3,012.50
Apr 12 2021 10:23pm
Quote (Killingyouall @ 12 Apr 2021 17:54)
It is an absolute sham.

Tampa has a stacked team due to cap exploitation.

They were able to keep players they should have never been able to afford and they loaded up at the deadline as well.

They should be punished for circumvention.


If Canucks did it, Bettman woulda sent his men alrdy and fine/punish the team haha
Member
Posts: 99,164
Joined: Nov 13 2004
Gold: 7,865.01
Apr 12 2021 10:51pm
Quote (Killingyouall @ Apr 12 2021 08:54pm)
It is an absolute sham.

Tampa has a stacked team due to cap exploitation.

They were able to keep players they should have never been able to afford and they loaded up at the deadline as well.

They should be punished for circumvention.


yeah
usually teams are like "good chance this players back by then"
but tsn and shit have been acting like its a sure thing for months now like hes been healthy for months now

1. id be pissed if i was kucherov if i was healthy and forced to sit
2. im pissed as a fan because like you said they are able to cheat the system and even add on a team already spending to the cap due to the exploitation
its really not fair and its wild the nhl is doing nothing about it this league is so bias its honestly bs

This post was edited by dragoneth on Apr 12 2021 10:51pm
Member
Posts: 28,247
Joined: May 27 2009
Gold: 18,101.00
Apr 13 2021 08:53pm
Quote (Secksii @ Apr 12 2021 09:23pm)
If Canucks did it, Bettman woulda sent his men alrdy and fine/punish the team haha


No doubt. Just ridiculous. Still mad over the Luongo recapture penalty tbh lol.
Go Back To Hockey Topic List
Prev1222922302231223222332487Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll