I'm a Seahawks fan(Rice's team) and I'm saying Johnson is way better than him.
Projections mean shit.

Gronk was projected for 12 when he hit 26.

omg egucci

sup

So then what makes a fair trade?

Witten, Gore, Manning
for
Gronk, Cutler, Murray?

Witten, Manning
for
Gronk, Cutler?

He wants to move Manning for an upgrade since he has Brees already.
And I said I'd move Gronkowski the other way..

So... How does this end up working out?

Manning for Gronk straight up maybe. At least that one makes sense

No it doesn't.

Then I have no TE and he has Witten and Gronk

Leaves me with 3 QB's in Freeman, Manning and Cutler.

We wanted to swap for upgrades/extra positional players.

Would you be happy with:

Rice | The only other good WR I have is Demarius Thomas. My next one is Darrius Heyward-Bay or Kenny Britt. Rice is my second best, which is why I put that in the offer for his 3rd best. (He chose Johnson).
Gronk
Murray
Freeman/Cutler

for

<Undetermined WR> | His choices are Reggie Wayne, Andre Johnson, Roddy White, Greg Little, Kevin Ogletree
Witten
Gore
Manning

Or is there no way to take a shit WR back from him at all and keep the rest?
Freeman you can argue is better than Cutler but that doesn't matter to him since he's playing Brees every week.


Can I not trade this?

<name> (Proj Rank/Actual Rank)
Witten (96/77)
Gore (57/19)
Manning (64/8)

Freeman (119/31)
Murray (19/113)
Gronkowski (13/9)

Doesn't seem that far off.

Johnson (27/101)
Rice (109/108)

They've both played in every game and Johnson has earned 1.4 more points than Rice has.
What makes it so unbearably uneven?

This post was edited by chreeeis on Oct 31 2012 09:15pm

I think you both are REALLY under valuing Manning.

That's all you got?
Because you think he's worth more than we do, we can't make a trade?

This post was edited by chreeeis on Oct 31 2012 09:22pm