Who is your top 3 defenseman of all time?

My input was Orr, Lidstrom, Bourque.

But everyone is saying Coffey should be in that list.

Am I wrong?

Are opinions wrong?

your input was correct

Pretty sure Doug Harvey is ranked #2 on most list. Then there's Bourque, Lidstrom, Shore, Potvin, etc..

I'd say Coffey is around #10 or 15 but it depends on how you rate all around play vs offense. Coffey is probably the best offensive defenseman of all time excluding Orr ( and Karlsson ).

Orr, Karlsson, Lidstrom

lidstrom and orr for sure, debatable order.

that 3rd spot is up for debate.

Input is input

As an Oilers fan I can't see how you take any of those 3 out for Coffey

This post was edited by McDavid on Jan 28 2019 05:57pm

i would put shore over coffey

Everyone always forgets about Kevin Bieksa

because he is forgettable