Answer whoever you think is better RIGHT now, or if you want - who you think will have the better career (more indicative of their team and not individual ability but i'd hear any argument)

Not trying to settle anything, just curious where everyone lies on this as I get mixed answers

Booker. Made it to the finals, in the west. Tatums success in the east is meh. The east sucks. But they're real close. Depends what you value more, defense or offense.

Was going to say the same, boils down to offense vs defense. Tatum has dropped 50 and 60, ecf(s) and had to play a great Lebron. Both still have time to hone in on their clutch gene, they both have a good heartbeat in that department already. East is like the AFC - somewhat depleted but the team that makes it out is always Championship caliber

This post was edited by tag_ohai on Oct 28 2021 11:35am

Tatum and it isn't even remotely close.

Booker and its not close

You voted for Tatum btw

Tatum

i dont think booker is top 10