Mlb Trade Deadline Discussion - Topic

Member

Posts: 3,951

Joined: May 10 2013

Gold: 0.00

Jul 30 2015 10:49pm

Quote (Benny21 @ Jul 30 2015 09:45pm)

Keith law's ranking of Mella has always been confusing. I'd put him as the third best arm in our system (maybe 4 is crick ever gets control) and probably 5th-7th best prospect overall. Adam Duvall doesn't impress me much.

It's a decent price for Leake who is a FA at seasons end but I'm not too broken up about it

That's actually Callis/Mayo ranking via MLBPIPELINE. I don't think it's too much to give up either. Mella still hasn't pitched above A ball and the Giants are trying to win now.

Benny21

Member

Posts: 60,666

Joined: Mar 3 2008

Gold: 809.00

#682

Jul 30 2015 10:51pm

Quote (HIROK @ Jul 30 2015 10:49pm)

That's actually Callis/Mayo ranking via MLBPIPELINE. I don't think it's too much to give up either. Mella still hasn't pitched above A ball and the Giants are trying to win now.

Ohh. Well FWIW Law has him #1 too lol. I'm seriously stunned Beede isn't #1 on more lists. I've seen him pitch in person twice and he's every bit as sharp as his scouting reports indicate. I would have driven to NY and killed Rohan if we gave up Beede

Proint

Member

Posts: 71,273

Joined: Mar 27 2007

Gold: 2,997.68

Warn: 10%

#683

Jul 30 2015 10:54pm

Quote (Benny21 @ Jul 30 2015 09:51pm)

Ohh. Well FWIW Law has him #1 too lol. I'm seriously stunned Beede isn't #1 on more lists. I've seen him pitch in person twice and he's every bit as sharp as his scouting reports indicate. I would have driven to NY and killed Rohan if we gave up Beede

jajaja

Member

Posts: 102,950

Joined: Jul 20 2006

Gold: 90.00

#684

Jul 30 2015 10:56pm

is this both possible value wise and financial wise (the latter for the mets)

not wheeler prospects for bruce

wheeler for reyes

or vice versa

HIROK

Member

Posts: 3,951

Joined: May 10 2013

Gold: 0.00

#685

Jul 30 2015 10:57pm

Quote (jajaja @ Jul 30 2015 09:56pm)

is this both possible value wise and financial wise (the latter for the mets)

not wheeler prospects for bruce

wheeler for reyes

or vice versa

>didn't want to give up wheeler for Gomez
>would give up wheeler for jose reyes
>lol
>mets

Benny21

Member

Posts: 60,666

Joined: Mar 3 2008

Gold: 809.00

#686

Jul 30 2015 10:59pm

Quote (jajaja @ Jul 30 2015 10:56pm)

is this both possible value wise and financial wise (the latter for the mets)

not wheeler prospects for bruce

wheeler for reyes

or vice versa

The better question is

why

HIROK

Member

Posts: 3,951

Joined: May 10 2013

Gold: 0.00

#687

Jul 30 2015 11:04pm

Quote (Benny21 @ Jul 30 2015 09:51pm)

@keithlaw 3m3 minutes ago
Hell yes it is. “@dabhimself: @keithlaw @karymack is it a smart move for the Giants in your opinion?”

well, there's that

jajaja

Member

Posts: 102,950

Joined: Jul 20 2006

Gold: 90.00

#688

Jul 30 2015 11:04pm

Quote (HIROK @ Jul 31 2015 12:57am)

>didn't want to give up wheeler for Gomez
>would give up wheeler for jose reyes
>lol
>mets

if theoretically i could get both bruce and reyes yes i'll give up wheeler.

jajaja

Member

Posts: 102,950

Joined: Jul 20 2006

Gold: 90.00

#689

Jul 30 2015 11:08pm

Quote (Benny21 @ Jul 31 2015 12:59am)

The better question is

why

remember when Wheeler's ceiling was higher than it is now the Giants gave him up for a quarter season rental in Beltran?

lol

Benny21

Member

Posts: 60,666

Joined: Mar 3 2008

Gold: 809.00

#690

Jul 30 2015 11:10pm

Quote (jajaja @ Jul 30 2015 11:08pm)

remember when Wheeler's ceiling was higher than it is now the Giants gave him up for a quarter season rental in Beltran?

lol

Are you really trying to step to me. Going for 4 rings in 6 years. Mets have, what, 4 rings in 60 years? Rolf

Edit; LOL ONLY 2

Quote (HIROK @ Jul 30 2015 11:04pm)

@keithlaw 3m3 minutes ago
Hell yes it is. “@dabhimself: @keithlaw @karymack is it a smart move for the Giants in your opinion?”

well, there's that

Enjoying the Leake

😎

This post was edited by Benny21 on Jul 30 2015 11:11pm

Go Back To Baseball Topic List