Quote (Madmartigan @ Jan 18 2013 01:52pm)
Carlos Pena hit .197 last season. Lance Berkman helped win a World Series two years ago with some clutch hits.
The two are not even comparable, IMO.
Quote (numone @ Jan 18 2013 01:58pm)
Berkman from 2011 was the best season he had in his career (offensively speaking) with a 163 wRC+. He is an average of 146 and the year before and after 2011 were 114 and 125 respectively.
Pena is an average 120 wRC+ and 2010-2012 he was 105,122,98.
Pena's biggest asset (his plus defense at first base) isn't helping his cause as a DH. For a 1-season deal it looks like Berkman would have been the better route, especially as DH'ing would be less wear and tare on his body. So I agree.
rofl you ignorant fools.
No way Berkman would have signed for what Pena did.
I still would take Pena barring same salary demands -- just wait till the end of 2013.