Whether or not you implied that, you framed this entire thread around osuna's chances at rookie of the year. Which is a yes or no thing and it makes no sense to make a thread about it if you wanted to learn something.
Its like me saying I want to learn what makes a player the most valuable NBA player by making a thread asking do you think Shane Larkin is the MVP?

This post was edited by ppkpkppk on Aug 30 2015 01:42am

As a student and teacher of writing, I must vouch this as a correct analysis of the topic of this thread as it was initially presented.

Glad we won't be seeing threads like this in the NFL section this year since his 49ers are a complete joke again

This is true unfortunately. We will probably see more Alex Smith threads comparing him and Kaepernick.

My point that Alex Smith was better for the niners was already proven

please stop bitg