Quote (SimCity @ Dec 10 2012 04:07am)
Swisher to Ichiro isn't a huge downgrade?
And Alex was a beast last season until he was bit by the injury bug. He's still a .270/.360/.440ish player with plus defense at 3B when he's healthy. I don't realistically expect that from Youk next season and there's a good chance he could fall off a cliff and become useless if you dig deeper into his decline.
Ichiro bounced back decently from 2011. He was a 2.6 WAR guy last year, and seemed comfortable in pinstripes. Its a downgrade from Swisher but I wouldn't consider it terrible.
Also, if you consider the outfield as a whole with Gardner coming back, then match Ichiro vs. our left field production last year and gardner vs. Swisher, it doesn't seem all that bad either.
And at 3rd, theres a chance we get a healthy A-Rod 2/3 of the way through the season. If Youk proceeds further into an abyss, then sure huge downgrade. But if he comes to this Yankees lineup with, if nothing else, better discipline at the plate, I think he can be a fine stopgap for whatever portion of the season. And we've managed to get decent enough production from declining veterans in recent years.