rizzo for cano?

i have
1b Chris Carter
1b Albert Pujols

2b Jonathon Schoop

fair?

This post was edited by BRYNihg24 on May 18 2016 10:56am

Would rather have Rizzo and Schoop

this

rizzo for jbj and kemp

Lmao, not even a little bit.
Rizzo >>>> by a lot.

E: don't leave your 1B as Carter and Pujols.. That'll fuck you.

This post was edited by xVitality on May 18 2016 01:12pm

What really? Can you explain why?

I feel like this would really help my OF

I just got Pujols off waivers for Gomez btw



This post was edited by BRYNihg24 on May 18 2016 01:29pm

1B is a deep position so you should always be able to have a good bat at the position. Rizzo is a top 20 bat overall, let alone just at 1st.

Kemp is nothing special (he's basically Khris Davis now) and JBJ is a peaks and valleys player. He just happens to be on a huge hot streak, same thing happened last year. Your OF is fine. Put Thomas in instead of Garcia and you're set. Especially with 2 utility slots, you can pick up literally anyone to fill in because you have extra OF.

Rizzo + anyone you get on waiver wire will almost surely give you more production than Kemp +JBJ. Especially when you only really need one OF.. And Thomas could be that guy.

If you're trading Rizzo, you need to get at least a top 10 OF back.

E: just wait for Peralta to come back. Thomas is 100% serviceable until then. If anything, you need a SS upgrade.

This post was edited by xVitality on May 18 2016 01:44pm

shortstop is definitely your weak point.

if you plan on shopping a sure fire top 25 player, at least look to improve at your worst position.


pujols isnt what he used to be. if he hits .230 this season with 30 homers youll be happy, and carter hasnt exactly shown to be consistent in years past.

if anything, look to move carter while hes at his peak.

This post was edited by Genetics on May 18 2016 01:53pm

Ok I wont do it haha. I have those two offers on the table (Cano or Kemp/JBJ) And Im trying to trade Rizzo for Harper straight up but the guy hasnt answered me

I may just keep my team as is. My OF just has no consistency and hasnt all year because of Upton, Gomez and Peralta. Surprisingly Hanley has been most consistent.

I have Villar at SS for the SBs. I got fucked by P.E.D Gordon and dropping Desmond too early lol

Wow cutting Desmond was a mistake. Cutting Dee Gordon was too.

You should pick him up ASAP if he's still there. And if he is, owners in your league be dumb