d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Draft Thread Discussion > To Free The Actual Thread Of Clutter
Prev15678976Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 46,112
Joined: Aug 23 2008
Gold: 8,472.65
May 30 2016 02:26pm
Quote (Voyaging @ May 30 2016 12:24pm)
We should decide on a method of deciding who wins because a lot of us will probably pick differently if we're making the team we think is personally the best vs the team we think other people will think is the best


I'm sure you'll have pages of stats that no one will care about. Lol
Member
Posts: 28,172
Joined: Mar 2 2009
Gold: 0.00
May 30 2016 02:27pm
Quote (Voyaging @ May 30 2016 03:24pm)
We should decide on a method of deciding who wins because a lot of us will probably pick differently if we're making the team we think is personally the best vs the team we think other people will think is the best



Opinion poll btw the 12 of us seems like the only viable option. Go szn by szn and vote on the 8 playoff teams, randomly seed them and then vote round by round
Member
Posts: 63,058
Joined: Jul 15 2005
Gold: 152.00
May 30 2016 02:28pm
Quote (Harasmussen @ May 30 2016 04:26pm)
I'm sure you'll have pages of stats that no one will care about. Lol


Ok what's your point?
Member
Posts: 46,112
Joined: Aug 23 2008
Gold: 8,472.65
May 30 2016 02:30pm
That it's all going to be opinion based
Member
Posts: 63,058
Joined: Jul 15 2005
Gold: 152.00
May 30 2016 02:30pm
Quote (LeSausage @ May 30 2016 04:27pm)
Opinion poll btw the 12 of us seems like the only viable option. Go szn by szn and vote on the 8 playoff teams, randomly seed them and then vote round by round


Works for me.

Though possibly instead of a playoff bracket we could do an elimination type thing where we get rid of one team at a time until 2 are left kinda like American Idol or w/e
Member
Posts: 102,950
Joined: Jul 20 2006
Gold: 90.00
May 30 2016 02:31pm
Definitely doing a voting system...the format isnt determined yet.

Obviously as is with all voting systems other people vote for or against your team


Might do a 2k simulation now that i have some off time, and make it a point system with a combo between the votes and 2k. But unsure about that now.
Member
Posts: 63,058
Joined: Jul 15 2005
Gold: 152.00
May 30 2016 02:31pm
Quote (Harasmussen @ May 30 2016 04:30pm)
That it's all going to be opinion based


Well I mean last year we started doing 2K simulations which isn't which is why I think we should figure it out. A lot of people were upset last draft because they voted for players that might be better IRL than on 2k

This post was edited by Voyaging on May 30 2016 02:32pm
Member
Posts: 102,950
Joined: Jul 20 2006
Gold: 90.00
May 30 2016 02:33pm
Quote (jajaja @ May 30 2016 04:31pm)
Definitely doing a voting system...the format isnt determined yet.

Obviously as is with all voting systems other people vote for or against your team


Might do a 2k simulation now that i have some off time, and make it a point system with a combo between the votes and 2k. But unsure about that now.


All teams will be given a chance to defend/support their team before votes occur


If were doing h2h playoff bracket this "defend ur team on why they beat team X" thing works well
Member
Posts: 63,058
Joined: Jul 15 2005
Gold: 152.00
May 30 2016 02:35pm
Quote (jajaja @ May 30 2016 04:33pm)
All teams will be given a chance to defend/support their team before votes occur


If were doing h2h playoff bracket this "defend ur team on why they beat team X" thing works well


It might not be the most fair, but I think h2h matchups would be the most fun

Maybe even do 2k simulations before voting. Make the simulations not actually play a role in scoring but just as an example of how the games could play out.

Just throwing out ideas
Member
Posts: 5,866
Joined: Jun 11 2014
Gold: 0.00
May 30 2016 02:47pm
I like the eliminate one at a time idea personally
Go Back To Sports Coliseum Topic List
Prev15678976Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll