Actually there are a bunch of great ones. Here's a short description of the top picks (in no particular order). Feel free to PM for more details. I enjoy talking anime!
Moribito: Guardian of the Spirit
Just watched this. Blown away. Not too far off from a masterpiece. I would recommend it if you enjoy fantasy and value realistic and emotional character relationships. If you watch it, I suggest subbed. Voice acting was top tier.
Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Don't judge this anime by its cover. Incredibly deep and dark, and definitely not a schoolgirl anime! Watch it if you enjoy excellent plot twists and difficult internal character struggles. Its only 12 episodes, so its an easy watch. If you decide to watch it, make sure you get through episode three. After that you'll probably be hooked. Also, greatest closing theme after ep 3! Masterpiece in my book.
FMA: Brotherhood or Original FMA
Pretty self explanatory. Classic masterpiece. Everyone ends up watching it so I'm not going to bother with a synopsis unless you ask for one.
Hunter x Hunter (2011)
Phenomenal battle shounen; arguably the best one. Deep characters, intelligent fights, and complex political maneuvering. If you need drawn out consistent action, you may not enjoy this as much. This is the battle anime for the thinker, not the casual viewer. Masterpiece.
Death Note
Near-masterpiece for anyone who enjoys complicated political action and heavy literary themes such as justice. Characters are great in the sense that the line is well blurred between protagonists and antagonists.
There are other good ones but I would say those are the best ones at the moment. All of them should be watched subbed except the FMA animes IMO. I recall Death Note being acceptable dubbed as well, but I'm not sure. PM if you want more details or info on other netflix anime on my list (check my profile).
This post was edited by WMKjsp on Sep 15 2015 06:56pm