You should watch both. Although i find amagami ss a bit......watered down.

Guess i'll watch bakemonogatari first, i've already downloaded it.

does fairy tail have discussion topic?

the manga does
http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=40692147&f=198&o=610

i don't know about the anime tho

downloaded about 800 gb worth of anime this week and having major trouble choosing what to watch first help plox
these are the ones that I'm the most eager to watch

Nana
Steins;Gate
Spice and Wolf II
Legend of the Galactic Heroes
Claymore
Ghost in the Shell
Great Teacher Onizuka
Baccano!
Hellsing Ultimate OVA
Elfen Lied
Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann
Cowboy Bebop
Gungrave
Rainbow: Nisha Rokubou no Shichinin
K-On!
Ef - A Tale of Memories
Gintama S1
Rurouni Kenshin: Tsuiokuhen
Samurai Champloo
Fate/Zero

my personal opinion. Does not mean not to watch the other stuff but I would watch this before watching the rest

if you want comedy
Great Teacher Onizuka - one of my old favorites
Gintama S1 (slow start but worth it in the end)

something more serious
Steins;Gate
Baccano! - Just recently watched this and one of the first anime I give a 10

other
Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann
Cowboy Bebop


Legend of the Galactic Heroes - I just started this so I can't make an opinion

This post was edited by LyZeR on Jan 18 2012 02:35am

I'll probably start with Steins;Gate then and watch a few episodes of Gintama once in a while Ty



That's mainly because I'm a sucker for HQ ^^ A whole bunch of the torrents are 40+ GBs. Still, I have some heavily time consuming watching to do these coming months.

elfen lied... all i gotta say

also i know what you mean, I cant stand shit quality so my harddrive is filled because blu-rays are so fucking large