what ur posting doesn't make sense

smoke fruit and gas fruit are different things

Last I checked smoke can make ppl cough and suffocate in excess.
Why else do we duck when there's a fire? Smoke rises and we don't wanna inhale those shit.

This post was edited by Uguu on Feb 7 2015 12:39am

last i check there has never been any implication of smoker's fruit being able to do this

what ur saying is they can extract oxygen out of everyone aka they can beat anyone aka they can easily beat all the 4 yonkous at once

yeah.... not a chance in hell.

luffy and zoro > smoker

Well from what I've seen smoker do for transportation (AKA fly by making his body into a smoke.) Why the fuck not?
I mean that's all he does with his fruit.
If we only infer from what we see then wtf kind of argument is that? Smoker has a sense of pride, aka won't kill people. Hence why he uses only his seastone sword or whatever instead of a sharp one.
Or why he let Luffy run away because he owed him and so on.
Smoker is fighting for his justice and that's not killing people.

Why can't Smoker use his fruit to make his whole body a smoke and go into people?

Well it would be co2 right? Which is the same thing as how people die from leaving their car on in their garage.

I'm not sure though if that's the kind of smoke it is.

thank you.. just something you can't wait to find out so gotta cheat a little and find out before hand lol

i wonder what will happen if:

Smoker transforms into a smoke, enter Caesar clowns body, Caesar then turns into a gas and enter sakazukis body.

=))))

They blow up like a volcano

there is no implication that he has ability to manipulate oxygen

smoke can be harmless depending on what causes it... theres no implication that he can make his smoke toxic, and he has never done it

so as far as i know its the weakest logia type

i didnt argue about smoker as a character. i just simply said he cannot defear luffy or zoro ar current stage in manga

Never said it can manipulate oxygen, or said it was toxic
Smoke can sufficate you regardless if its as thick as smoker looks. Since it can block all oxygen intake..