Just watched
Yosuga no Sora and even though I WTF'd with annoyance quite a few times during the show, it gave off a nice and soothing feeling. Probably thanks the high quality VA, well-drawn environments & character designs and the absolutely amazing OP.
It was in omnibus format (the main pursued a relationship with a girl and then the show reserved and he gets a different girl) which made things feel pretty rushed since they obviously had to go out of their way to shove a goddamn forced sex scene down my throat in the end of each route.
Still, it was probably the best way to go in order to avoid turning into a School Days 2.0 and having another infamous boat ride ending

The last episodes are reaaally controversial and deals with the sexual relationship between Haru and Sora, reunited orphan
twins. I guess that route was probably the reason why many wanted to watch the series in the first place and it gets one episode more than the other to show it's importance.
While it certainly featured the most dramatic and emotional episodes you can't help but feel uneasy as two twins all of a sudden confess their strong & repressed romantic feelings for each other. Especially when all the other routes have implied it being 100% one-sided.
Oh, and the Sora route definitely had the most satisfying ending. While it was pretty ambiguous, all interpretations would pretty much be considered happy for Sora and Haru, sad for all their friends and bittersweet for us watchers.
Overall, a very high-quality production which, while it fails to deliver on many selling points, is ultimately well worth watching for a fan of the romance, ecchi or harem genres if you can stomach the "most canonical" route being about twincest (I just had to use that expression at least once).
7/10Quote (zarkadon @ Feb 7 2012 06:14pm)
I still have to watch Gosick, I need to get though some other animes first, but I plan to watch it soon.
I'll look into Shakugan no Shana, I hadn't heard of it before

Gonna give Gosick a go before the others I think. Just need to finish a few things that I've had on-hold first

Go ahead and do that! Tons of people have been recommending it to me and I'm a fan of the genre too so I'm sure it'll be great! There also is a second season and the third is airing right now and they all have high rating :>
This post was edited by GuZ on Feb 7 2012 12:17pm