d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Entertainment Room > Anime > Anime Is Hack Art
Prev13456713Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
Views: 1493Replies: 120Track Topic
Member
Posts: 21,028
Joined: Dec 12 2008
Gold: 1.50
#41
Nov 30 2012 03:59pm
Quote (QQL @ Nov 30 2012 04:58pm)
there, you just contradicted yourself


lol how? Please explain how I contradicted myself.
Member
Posts: 23,966
Joined: Jul 8 2007
Gold: 137.01
#42
Nov 30 2012 04:00pm
Quote (QQL @ Nov 30 2012 02:58pm)
there, you just contradicted yourself


Member
Posts: 7,179
Joined: Feb 2 2009
Gold: 130.05
#43
Nov 30 2012 04:03pm
Quote (Touhou @ Nov 30 2012 02:56pm)
So basically your biased as hell opinion = any art is crap.


That's what I got from this
Member
Posts: 7,179
Joined: Feb 2 2009
Gold: 130.05
#44
Nov 30 2012 04:03pm
Quote (Paran0id @ Nov 30 2012 02:59pm)
lol how? Please explain how I contradicted myself.


If he honestly has to explain you should try tutoring .
Member
Posts: 21,028
Joined: Dec 12 2008
Gold: 1.50
#45
Nov 30 2012 04:05pm
Quote (Shoujo @ Nov 30 2012 05:03pm)
If he honestly has to explain you should try tutoring .


well, humour me anyway. How is what I said in any way, shape or form a contradiction?
Member
Posts: 6,887
Joined: Sep 20 2008
Gold: 14,100.00
#46
Nov 30 2012 04:11pm
Quote (Paran0id @ Nov 30 2012 01:53pm)
Bullshit. Just because I myself am not an artist doesn't mean I can't criticize art that others produce.
And yeah different people have different preferences in art but that doesn't meant that certain art is not better or worse than others. Art can be judged, despite what you and the majority of people may claim.


How can you criticize something you have little knowledge or experience in? You can't, you may state your opinion about it but you cannot criticize it. However if your opinion goes against the norm of society or the majority without providing adequate evidence to support your point besides personal feelings then your opinion is incorrect. Its like if everyone in the world stated that the world is flat, and you are the only one saying the world is round. You are wrong even if your right. If you provideevidence however people may agree that you are infact correct. Society and people dictate what is wrong or not, not yourself.
I respect your opinion although I don't agree with it. I just dont think there was a point in saying something like that, especially when nothin benefitial would come out of it.

This post was edited by Yinnyiin on Nov 30 2012 04:13pm
Member
Posts: 21,028
Joined: Dec 12 2008
Gold: 1.50
#47
Nov 30 2012 04:16pm
Quote (Yinnyiin @ Nov 30 2012 05:11pm)
How can you criticize something you have little knowledge or experience in? You can't, you may state your opinion about it but you cannot criticize it. However if your opinion goes against the norm of society or the majority without providing adequate evidence to support your point besides personal feelings then your opinion is incorrect. Its like if everyone in the world stated that the world is flat, and you are the only one saying the world is round. You are wrong even if your right. If  you provideevidence however people may agree that you are infact correct. Society and people dictate what is wrong or not, not yourself.
I respect your opinion although I don't agree with it. I just dont think there was a point in saying something like that, especially when nothin benefitial would come out of it.


I have enough knowledge of art to criticize it. Appreciating art does not necessarily require one to have artistic talent. And what I'm saying isn't exactly uncommon. Lots of people take my view that art can be judged. These kids are getting all pissy because I chose to judge their precious anime cartoons, which are, in fact, garbage.
Member
Posts: 21,764
Joined: Mar 6 2008
Gold: 646.01
#48
Nov 30 2012 04:30pm
Quote (Paran0id @ Nov 30 2012 05:16pm)
I have enough knowledge of art to criticize it. Appreciating art does not necessarily require one to have artistic talent. And what I'm saying isn't exactly uncommon. Lots of people take my view that art can be judged. These kids are getting all pissy because I chose to judge their precious anime cartoons, which are, in fact, garbage.


Quote (Paran0id @ Nov 30 2012 05:05pm)
well, humour me anyway. How is what I said in any way, shape or form a contradiction?


What are you exactly trying to prove? You acknowledge the fact the opinions and preferences will vary between different individuals, so why try to validate your opinion as a fact?

Do you see the flaw in your way of reasoning just as this entire community does?
Member
Posts: 21,028
Joined: Dec 12 2008
Gold: 1.50
#49
Nov 30 2012 04:53pm
This post is a violation of the site rules and appropriate action was taken.

Quote (QQL @ Nov 30 2012 05:30pm)
What are you exactly trying to prove? You acknowledge the fact the opinions and preferences will vary between different individuals, so why try to validate your opinion as a fact?

Do you see the flaw in your way of reasoning just as this entire community does?


Lol okay. I see the problem here. You're an idiot. You're basically saying that because opinions exist, they cannot be validated.
Do you not realize how stupid you sound? I did not contradict myself.
Member
Posts: 54,046
Joined: Jun 1 2010
Gold: 1.74
#50
Nov 30 2012 04:54pm
i can draw landscape art pretty good but i can't even touch anime. those artist are at another level. especially the famous ones.

Quote (Paran0id @ 30 Nov 2012 18:53)
Lol okay. I see the problem here. You're an idiot. You're basically saying that because opinions exist, they cannot be validated.
Do you not realize how stupid you sound? I did not contradict myself.


actually your pretty stupid.

This post was edited by ChrisKz on Nov 30 2012 04:55pm
Go Back To Anime Topic List
Prev13456713Next
Closed New Topic New Poll

© 2003-2026 d2jsp  Contact