d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Entertainment Room > Anime > Casual Anime Watcher Here, Why Do Ppl Say Manga
Prev13456710Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 26,802
Joined: Aug 14 2006
Gold: 15.00
Oct 18 2012 10:31am
Quote (AWHavoc @ Oct 18 2012 10:28am)
In manga you don't have to deal with shitty voice actors.

(For example, the Japanese voice actor for Goku) (dubs are shit btw, subs are superior)

Comparing Manga to anime is like comparing books to movies.

A bunch of illiterate fuck-tards will come along saying movies are better than books, but the people that have any sort of reading comprehension skills know the truth.

(If you can't feel emotion from written text, you may be retarded... or you probably have A.D.D. and couldn't handle subs anyway...)



I honestly prefer
LN
Manhwa/Manga
Anime (subbed)
Getting stabbed for 30 minutes
Anime(dubbed)

must be trollin mangas arnt like books at all
Member
Posts: 40,339
Joined: Jan 21 2006
Gold: 88.00
Oct 18 2012 11:16am
i only know of three animes that are better than the mangas cause the manga sucks

FLCL - manga was random as hell even worse than the ovas
Sword Art Online - pls. manga was terrible made me want to stab myself
Prince of Tennis - cause you don't see Dinosaurs being blown into the court in the manga (THE ONLY REASON)
Member
Posts: 5,185
Joined: Mar 21 2006
Gold: 592.63
Oct 18 2012 11:38am
SAO isn't a good example since the original work is a light novel.
Member
Posts: 17,213
Joined: Jun 28 2006
Gold: 7,554.70
Oct 18 2012 03:00pm
they are both good.. saying one is better then the other is a matter of opinion.. so its stupid as all hell to argue about it.
Member
Posts: 22,657
Joined: Dec 14 2007
Gold: 352.00
Oct 18 2012 03:15pm
Quote (zanders @ Oct 17 2012 08:07pm)
the black and white gives me cancer too, if there were some colors in manga i might of liked it better


if it was all coloured it would probably take a lot longer to release
seeing as a lot of series do weekly releases

Quote (PyourK @ Oct 18 2012 02:38pm)
SAO isn't a good example since the original work is a light novel.


agreed

This post was edited by douglas22888 on Oct 18 2012 03:19pm
Member
Posts: 54,057
Joined: Jun 1 2010
Gold: 1.74
Oct 18 2012 11:51pm
honestly when i first startedanime i hated manga too. It's okay. I actually prefer it in black and white. and i can finish stotries a lot faster by reading than watching.
Member
Posts: 10,780
Joined: Jul 22 2011
Gold: 655.00
Oct 19 2012 12:01am
goku goes ssj 1 anime = entire episode

Goku goes ssj 1 manga = 4 pages

gohan goes ssj 2 anime = entire episode

gohan goes ssj 2 manga = 9 pages


other reasons is what is in the anime and not in the manga or vice versa.

kensin anime leaves out the entire arc explaining the cross shapped scar, while theres about 5 enitre volumes after the anime drops off in manga.

naruto flows from the younger years to the older years in the manga, in the anime theres what seems like endless worthless quests at the end untill you get to shippuden.

dragon ball and dragon ball z have worthless filler for entire episodes, liek the gralic jr. arc dosnt even exist in the manga.

and in dragon ball when goku first goes to kami to train, there are several episodes in the anime showing gokus training, while in the manga its left out, as its quite un necessiary.

manga is alot better then anime.

Quote (hurt_knee @ Oct 18 2012 12:31pm)
must be trollin mangas arnt like books at all


no see, hes saying books are to movies as mangas are to anime. not that mangas are like books.

This post was edited by Ylem122 on Oct 19 2012 12:06am
Banned
Posts: 808
Joined: Oct 5 2012
Gold: 190.00
Warn: 30%
Oct 19 2012 12:58am
Anime has fillers, a bunch of pointless random shit usually thrown in and rarely is an anime done with justice to the manga. If you watch an anime before ever touching the manga (if one exists for that anime) it probably won't bother you, but for people like me that usually read the story first it's incredibly annoying and retarded how most anime's go, hell the first FMA didn't follow the manga for shit as an example. So for me, manga is superior for story. Obviously anime is superior for fights and action.
Member
Posts: 3,621
Joined: Jul 12 2010
Gold: 0.00
Oct 19 2012 01:02am
This whole thread

My tastes > your tastes

Member
Posts: 10,780
Joined: Jul 22 2011
Gold: 655.00
Oct 19 2012 01:51am
Quote (TheResistance @ Oct 19 2012 03:02am)
This whole thread

My tastes > your tastes


but my tastes are better then your tastes, or atleast manga is better then anime.

most people who prefer anime really dont have that much expericen with manga.

most people who prefer manga, probly started off watching anime and have plenty of experience with both.

so given their respecitve experience in the field of asian catoons, the manga fans opinion is more qualified.

also it seems most people are agreeing that mangas are better in this thread.
Go Back To Anime Topic List
Prev13456710Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll