d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Entertainment Room > Anime >
Poll > Clannad Overated Poll?
Prev12345Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 7,179
Joined: Feb 2 2009
Gold: 130.05
Nov 30 2012 09:20pm
Quote (TheResistance @ Nov 30 2012 07:37pm)
I would only say it's over rated  on MAL and other sites with lots of new watchers, where everyone thinks its the best.
Most people in this subforum would say its good but not the best, and in general people either love it or hate it so I wouldn't say its over rated


I don't get why people treat MAL and other sites like a bible.

I mean , sure its convenient , I personally use it as a catalog.

I remember before MAL , there was an actual anime encyclopedia hard copy ... guess the internet took it out of hand :lol:
Member
Posts: 22,657
Joined: Dec 14 2007
Gold: 352.00
Nov 30 2012 09:23pm
Quote (Shoujo @ Nov 30 2012 11:20pm)
I don't get why people treat MAL and other sites like a bible.

I mean , sure its convenient , I personally use it as a catalog.

I remember before MAL , there was an actual anime encyclopedia hard copy ... guess the internet took it out of hand :lol:


i mainly use it for keeping track of what i watch and whatnot, but i also use it to check if something new has popped up that i might be interested in so i can throw it on my ptw
although sometimes it seems to be kinda behind at times
Member
Posts: 3,621
Joined: Jul 12 2010
Gold: 0.00
Nov 30 2012 09:23pm
Quote (douglas22888 @ Dec 1 2012 04:14pm)
honestly i really enjoy it
started reading the novels like 4-5 eps in
and it has kept pretty close to the original content, save for some compressed scenes, addition of side story characters in some scenes (they didn't originally exist in volume 1), and that chapter they skipped :(


Yea some of the eps are entertaining but when it reaches a retarded moment or scene, or plot hole, I just can not enjoy the rest of the episode lol
Member
Posts: 22,657
Joined: Dec 14 2007
Gold: 352.00
Nov 30 2012 09:24pm
Quote (TheResistance @ Nov 30 2012 11:23pm)
Yea some of the eps are entertaining but when it reaches a retarded moment or scene, or plot hole, I just can not enjoy the rest of the episode lol


honestly i can't think of any plot holes off the top of my head
Member
Posts: 9,931
Joined: Mar 22 2011
Gold: 1,390.00
Nov 30 2012 09:58pm
Quote (douglas22888 @ Dec 1 2012 04:00am)
prob sao, waiting til it's finished to give it #1 if it earns it which so far it probably will, but we'll see since i am slightly peeved they skipped an entire chapter >.<


imo the second arc was not really bad or good after I'll watch the end obviously, whereas the first arc was really nice. Finally sao stays a good anime, battles don't take so long time, interesting story. I also enjoy it so far but less than the first episodes.
btw I only watch sao in Anime. Perhaps in novels, we can enjoy it more than in anime.
Member
Posts: 22,657
Joined: Dec 14 2007
Gold: 352.00
Nov 30 2012 10:00pm
Quote (AFKHunters @ Nov 30 2012 11:58pm)
imo the second arc was not really bad or good after I'll watch the end obviously, whereas the first arc was really nice. Finally sao stays a good anime, battles don't take so long time, interesting story. I also enjoy it so far but less than the first episodes.
btw I only watch sao in Anime. Perhaps in novels, we can enjoy it more than in anime.


it's worth reading if you ever get a chance
there are some smaller details better explained in the novels i find
Member
Posts: 2,726
Joined: Aug 3 2007
Gold: 92,610.00
Nov 30 2012 10:53pm
people might overrate it, but it's good overall
Member
Posts: 3,621
Joined: Jul 12 2010
Gold: 0.00
Dec 1 2012 08:12pm
Quote (douglas22888 @ Dec 1 2012 04:24pm)
honestly i can't think of any plot holes off the top of my head


I try to forget them so I don't stay mad for a whole week
But the newest episode, when she drops the admin card. Jesus christ that was retarded
Member
Posts: 10,825
Joined: Jun 8 2009
Gold: 3,399.70
Dec 2 2012 01:50pm
This question is asked too much. I don't want to bother giving my opinion so here's a different opinion.

Tomoyo da bes.
Member
Posts: 15,990
Joined: Nov 2 2008
Gold: 4,029.00
Dec 2 2012 04:12pm
Quote (TsukiBaka @ 2 Dec 2012 20:50)
Tomoyo da bes.

i congratulate you to your excellent taste
Go Back To Anime Topic List
Prev12345Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll