I disrespect and never think anything of it. I respond because you still pm'd me after I said I have the right to ignore. Im not an that much of an ass. Im not judging. You have a preference and I simply think its a bad one.
What you're comparing cannot be compared. They are 2 very different things fundamentally.
In this case of matter, its like saying K-on is better than something like Rurouni Kenshin or even cowboy bebop . I guarantee you that there are people who will back this statement up. But guess what, regardless of Opinion, this is indeed rubbish.
Anyways, I'm done debating about this.
Quote (Shoujo @ Jan 17 2013 07:08pm)
Lol I just hate the whole" lets act like an anime character and speak broken Japanese" thing , it bugs the hell out of me , lol so I guess all of it haha .
I mean in terms of expression , of course the original language will always be better . No doubt about it . But I don't think I can ever rule out dubs entirely lol . Because even when you read subs, you are reading that persons interpretation on the expression.
So if the person translating isn't a very expressive person, the emotion might get lost in translation . This even happens with the more popular sub groups . Also the main reason why most dubs suck , actors with no emotion .
I agree. I've watched many dubs in my life, and I actually always take a look at them when they become available. And yes, thats exactly why most dubs suck. But specifically for Japanese and how the Japanese language itself works. It's almost impossible to get everything if it were to be dubbed any other language.
Ie. Saying Hime and then it as to hide it, he says -gaki for Hime-gaki. This is impossible for probably any language I believe, obviously in english.
Some anime don't ever have this problem, but anything that isn't its original (specifically animation and language) will lose its CREATED value great or small no matter what.