d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Entertainment Room > Anime > One Piece Manga Discussion > ~discuss The Manga Only~
Prev1179180181182183753Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 45,618
Joined: Apr 10 2006
Gold: 113,270.08
Oct 16 2010 02:28am
Quote (Eep @ 15 Oct 2010 21:03)
OP will never become crap because that would be implying that ODA is on the same level as Tite or Kishimoto, which he obviously isn't.


the truth is, the 2/3 of OP was a crap. I barely watched them all. Since whitebeard war, it was uber good. I would give 3/10 to the first 2/3 of OP and 10/10 to now
Member
Posts: 5,892
Joined: Jul 12 2008
Gold: 828.35
Oct 16 2010 02:33am
Quote (undead_lord @ Oct 16 2010 04:28pm)
the truth is, the 2/3 of OP was a crap. I barely watched them all. Since whitebeard war, it was uber good. I would give 3/10 to the first 2/3 of OP and 10/10 to now


http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2646/3910516856_1d98f1ee3e.jpg
Member
Posts: 17,094
Joined: Oct 16 2008
Gold: 6,669.61
Oct 16 2010 02:52am
Quote (undead_lord @ Oct 16 2010 10:28am)
the truth is, the 2/3 of OP was a crap. I barely watched them all. Since whitebeard war, it was uber good. I would give 3/10 to the first 2/3 of OP and 10/10 to now




Which manga have you been readin'?
Member
Posts: 11,153
Joined: Aug 23 2008
Gold: 4,230.00
Oct 16 2010 03:18am
Quote (undead_lord @ Oct 16 2010 03:28am)
the truth is, the 2/3 of OP was a crap. I barely watched them all. Since whitebeard war, it was uber good. I would give 3/10 to the first 2/3 of OP and 10/10 to now


since you said watch i'm assuming you mean the anime.. Even though I personally like the anime (the HD versions) . If you watch the earlier episodes with standard definition it seems to be done horribly. But on the slim chance you mean manga then I believe you are terribly mistaken. Especially if you read it from beginning to end. And it is wrong to compare a end part of the manga to a beginning part. Because that way you start looking for things that the characters now can do that they couldn't at time. In all they look horribly weak when you reread the beginning chapters and it almost seems boring because you think, "that should have been easy".
Member
Posts: 45,618
Joined: Apr 10 2006
Gold: 113,270.08
Oct 16 2010 05:25am
i watched anime until whitebeard war and the story seemed to be a little childish to me. Bleach had also bad start (and bad finish). Only naruto kept me excited from beginning

the most excited parts from OP, bleach, naruto:

Ichigo rescuing Rukia > 2 years later in OP > whole naruto shippuden

Member
Posts: 11,153
Joined: Aug 23 2008
Gold: 4,230.00
Oct 16 2010 07:08am
Quote (undead_lord @ Oct 16 2010 06:25am)
i watched anime until whitebeard war and the story seemed to be a little childish to me. Bleach had also bad start (and bad finish). Only naruto kept me excited from beginning

the most excited parts from OP, bleach, naruto:

Ichigo rescuing Rukia > 2 years later in OP > whole naruto shippuden


2 years later in OP is an obvious one =P ... as that just means after time-skip meaning the new chapters.. It seems like One Piece just gets better and better with each new arc. =P.

But if you are talking about anime as it is kinda hard to tell as you only mention anime. there has yet to be a 2 year mark in One Piece in the anime. as the current story line only consists of about 8 months =P
Member
Posts: 45,618
Joined: Apr 10 2006
Gold: 113,270.08
Oct 16 2010 08:17am
Quote (kasey21 @ 16 Oct 2010 14:08)
2 years later in OP is an obvious one =P ... as that just means after time-skip meaning the new chapters.. It seems like One Piece just gets better and better with each new arc. =P.

But if you are talking about anime as it is kinda hard to tell as you only mention anime. there has yet to be a 2 year mark in One Piece in the anime. as the current story line only consists of about 8 months =P


anime and manga are same for me. The story is what it makes the best
Member
Posts: 25,660
Joined: Mar 16 2008
Gold: 3.60
Oct 16 2010 10:42am
wtf how can u not like one piece before the whitebeard war
makes no sense

captain kuro
don krieg with his beast armor
arlong
crocodile
enel the fucking thunder god
CP FUCKING 9?!?!
though i gotta admit i was a little unsatisfied with moria
luffy vs usopp?!?!

u are not a true one piece fan if u did not think all of these fights were epic and only liking one piece for the whitebeard war

Member
Posts: 25,660
Joined: Mar 16 2008
Gold: 3.60
Member
Posts: 23,862
Joined: Aug 16 2006
Gold: 20.00
Oct 16 2010 10:59am
Quote (undead_lord @ Oct 16 2010 03:28am)
the truth is, the 2/3 of OP was a crap. I barely watched them all. Since whitebeard war, it was uber good. I would give 3/10 to the first 2/3 of OP and 10/10 to now


truth is, naruto was good until sasuke left the village then it was a steaming pile of poo


so...it was good for like 1/10 of the manga


OP has been amazing since the arlong arc. If you though OP was childish, then you sir, are the one who's a child. If you can't understand the concepts of drama in the show then you clearly aren't old enough to understand the show period.


The build up to the sand arc alone was amazing....the drama from enies lobby, the adventure @ sky island...etc


childish? Maybe the art style is a bit cartoony at times...but whoa, forgive me for watching a fictional anime.



Naruto fan calling OP childish? Just blows my mind....naruto is so mind numbingly stupid and full of cliche sometimes that I am surprised I kept reading it.


I ALWAYS look forward to the next chapter of OP. Can't say the same for naruto or bleach, or ANY other manga for that matter.
Go Back To Anime Topic List
Prev1179180181182183753Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll