Quote (Juicy_J @ Aug 25 2012 06:41pm)
Like I said, I already acknowledged that we could find out the other truths about Kakashi without him being alive. The fact is, you don't have any other evidence either besides "it's a manga" which I've already acknowledged. And truthfully, I don't have any other evidence other than the fact that the subject hasn't been brought up to or by anyone else. So in short, we're basically at a stalemate due to unknown information (being whether or not someone else knows the answers to those Kakashi-related questions) and to be honest either one of our conclusions are very plausible.
Yeah, you don't need Kakashi to land the hit and Minato "beat" him with speed but that doesn't change the fact that the only hits they've landed on him were because of Kakashi. Without him, yeah I'm confident that they would land something eventually but they probably wouldn't have done so half as easily and they could further exhaust themselves in the process. And how do you know that Naruto, Bee and Gai WOULDN'T be struggling without Kakashi there? That point is just as impossible to prove, don't try it. Just because they're all fast doesn't mean they can just batter Tobi around. They're not doing so right now, even with Kakashi there. Why is it so hard to fathom that Kakashi is a vital part of the story, much more so than Gai?
And you're right, this Madara > himself at the time where he fought Hashirama. Madara with the Rinnegan might beat Hashirama but even now Madara kept saying "only Hashirama can defeat me" so that's all speculation, too. IMO, this Madara minus the wood release would probably beat Hashirama. But hey, maybe there's some way for the Senju side to get the Rinnegan too O_o I hope so.
easily? you call kakashi being half dead easily? you mean the same kakashi who you claim is vital to this fight but seems like he cant even perform anymore? Hrm?~!~ if thats the case we can remove any of the 4 and say the other 3 would be dead. naruto stopped the 5 bijuu bomb thing(arguably gai could have stopped it with 8 gates and maybe even tobi but die in the process leaving 2 alive :p) remove gai naruto would be dead cause he was saved in the beginning from being absorbed by tobi by kakashi and gai more so since the attack was what made him go to the other dimension i fail atm to remember what bee did to save others but it seems like bee and kakashi could be removed and have the remaining 2 alive at this point
so yeah even with kakashi they are still struggling and imo he's the least needed in this fight score 1 for stamina!
i never once said in a serious manner(it escapes me if i even said it as a joke) that gai > kakashi story wise. i do however frequently state gai > kakashi battle wise and going by this war in terms of actual battling i would take gai his experience with even keeping kakashi among others focused is top notch i also frequently say SPECULATION! although i do use some facts to back it without an actual fight by kishi such as the 1st vs madara and madara claiming without a doubt the 1st> him
so yeah dont twist my words i simply argued that kakashi wasnt needed for a background on how he obtained anything FACT
and that he is currently exhausted physically FACT
This post was edited by Charity on Aug 25 2012 06:14pm