d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Entertainment Room > Anime > Do You Think Humans Can Fly?
Prev1121314
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 9,834
Joined: Feb 27 2008
Gold: 157.41
Dec 6 2013 03:10pm
Quote (Malidry @ Dec 6 2013 07:15am)
Why because your head is stuck up your ass? You give no concrete answers other than the fact you can't understand it.


You see how I'm talking calmly and only giving my own beliefs and you continue to attack me due to your own arrogance? Enlightening......it's almost like I'm talking to one of my bible thumping red neck hick relatives. Hue.
Member
Posts: 16,683
Joined: Jan 2 2009
Gold: 90.00
Dec 6 2013 05:09pm
Quote (LindeRKV @ Dec 6 2013 09:11am)
In the end, you are repeating same things over and over again. I haven't stated once that human can fly. You cannot say though human will never fly. If you did then you would be lying. Not because human will fly once but because you would be just stating what you don't know.

It is your freedom to stay close-minded. However, look around yourself and questing popular beliefs and rules. You will be much easier to let go old rules when it appears they don't apply anymore. Speaking of scientists, there are too many to count them up now, that don't believe world is set by current rules. They put their lives in proving it. And world is way beyond understanding what you can see or touch. It is about understanding what remains invisible from us. Universe is mystery and we belong in it - we are mystery of our own. It is likely that we will understand time and space before we understand ourselves, though.


yes, I am.

I do not need to dance around the topic like OP

I do not open my mind to claims without evidence.

This post was edited by Vocaloid on Dec 6 2013 05:11pm
Member
Posts: 3,598
Joined: Dec 2 2008
Gold: 0.00
Dec 6 2013 06:41pm
Quote (GoGoData @ 6 Dec 2013 15:10)
You see how I'm talking calmly and only giving my own beliefs and you continue to attack me due to your own arrogance? Enlightening......it's almost like I'm talking to one of my bible thumping red neck hick relatives. Hue.


You haven't attacked me once because you're so calm and righteous? You haven't insinuated that my ideas are wrong and that your ideas are right? really? you haven't? so enlightening, no wonder you're related to red neck bible thumping hicks!

Quote (Vocaloid @ 6 Dec 2013 17:09)
yes, I am.

I do not need to dance around the topic like OP

I do not open my mind to claims without evidence.


so you admit your mind is closed - and at the same time there is no way you could ever know everything. right? you can't know everything, everything there is to know has not been known.

Quote (Boblacolle @ 6 Dec 2013 14:44)
Ok so first and foremost, why the f*** has this debate become a argument against or for a dualism body/mind. I was pretty motivated to read all the thread until I saw this turn into a dualism of substances debate.

To OP:

All your claims have many premisses on which there already has been a great debate over the course of history.

Can we have metaphysical claims?
Is there only one substance?
Can we pretend to a knowledge of something that would be outside of what we call nature?
Can we do an ontology of science?
What is the social role of science and scientific claims?

You started your thread by asking whether it would be possible for humans to fly or not. At first, I thought that the only way to discuss this was in an evolutionary perspective. Could we, humans, evolved into flying human (or something like this). There could have a been a nice discussion about how an organism evolve, what makes him evolve, how does he evolve, etc. From there, could the human evolve into a flying being and if yes, how could it happen?

But instead, after several posts, you started talking about souls, multiverse, and those metaphysical claims which hold no grounds to what we know about that so called ''reality''.

Theres one thing I would add: People refuting what you are saying are not pretending to know everything. Anyone saying that humans know everything there is to know in a manner such as no more revolutionary discovery in science will be made is plain stupid. This being said, science seems to offer a frame in which we can describe, explain and predict a lot of natural phenomenas. If you want to offer some new frame where humans are divided into a soul and a body, where multiverse are higly anthropomorphic (such as a planet being ruled by apes...), where you can believe what you want the truth to be cause otherwise the world ''sux'', where you can channel some mystic energy into your body, you have to give us a strong reason. Some people will jump on such topic and will gladly but heartlessly show how you fall short on your premisses.

The core question is to ask if you have a better alternative, not to know if science is always 100% accurate.


Why does flying have to be constricted to flesh and blood? You bring up the possibility of biotech mechanisms, but you dismiss the possibility of spirit capabilities? Why? Is it because you could plausibly explain an Iron Man suit that allows people to fly, but it would be harder to explain a spirit existing through time and space on another level than our metaphysical world?

Just because you can't explain it doesn't mean it doesn't exist. Isaac Newton and Albert Einstein themselves questioned the existence of spirit worlds, God, angels and demons, heaven and hell, and many other things that could not and still can not be explained.

People specifically in this thread refuting what I'm saying are literally pretending to know everything. It sounds like a grand claim to make, but they are literally claiming to know everything. Physics and logic are all that exist to Valconoid, he said it clear as day?

You use words such as SEEM and PREDICT, meaning that they are not 100% accurate. Therefore you CAN'T know, you DON'T know. Stop trying to pretend like the world is controllable, it's not.

Where I can believe what I WANT the truth to be? A man knows that what he wants isn't always what matters, but what needs to be. I'm not on here claiming to know anything other than the fact that it is impossible for us to prove much of anything as absolute truth.

I DON'T have to give you a strong reason, you can't refute it.

Science is not 100% accurate, I can say that with a certainty. Would you really say that there has never been an event that happened that could not be explained by science? Not for a lack of knowledge, but literally COULD NOT be measured by the greatest minds in the universe no matter how badly they wanted to? You think things happen randomly? Do we live our lives accidental like and whatever happens happens? Are we existing on a combination of random occurences combined with our own choices? Or are we living in a universe that is dictated by how far you can measure a test tube up your ass?
Member
Posts: 9,834
Joined: Feb 27 2008
Gold: 157.41
Dec 6 2013 07:59pm
Talking about useless walls of text |0()|
Member
Posts: 3,481
Joined: Oct 23 2013
Gold: 0.00
Dec 6 2013 08:15pm
There are things that can't be explained, but by saying it must be god (and using that as a reason) is really irrational and prevents any scientific progress. If its unknown its unknown.

Member
Posts: 5,037
Joined: Dec 18 2010
Gold: 41,609.40
Dec 6 2013 08:53pm
Wow 14 pages and i didn't even help create this.

kudos

This post was edited by iCK on Dec 6 2013 08:53pm
Member
Posts: 3,598
Joined: Dec 2 2008
Gold: 0.00
Dec 6 2013 08:59pm
Quote (ButOniiChanILoveYou @ 6 Dec 2013 20:15)
There are things that can't be explained, but by saying it must be god (and using that as a reason) is really irrational and prevents any scientific progress. If its unknown its unknown.


Who said it must be God?
Quote (GoGoData @ 6 Dec 2013 19:59)
Talking about useless walls of text |0()|


Yea I wouldn't respond to someone who just threw my face in the dirt either.

Member
Posts: 7,459
Joined: Jul 31 2009
Gold: 3,618.00
Dec 7 2013 12:41am
Quote (Malidry @ 6 Dec 2013 20:41)
You haven't attacked me once because you're so calm and righteous? You haven't insinuated that my ideas are wrong and that your ideas are right? really? you haven't? so enlightening, no wonder you're related to red neck bible thumping hicks!



so you admit your mind is closed - and at the same time there is no way you could ever know everything. right? you can't know everything, everything there is to know has not been known.



Why does flying have to be constricted to flesh and blood? You bring up the possibility of biotech mechanisms, but you dismiss the possibility of spirit capabilities? Why? Is it because you could plausibly explain an Iron Man suit that allows people to fly, but it would be harder to explain a spirit existing through time and space on another level than our metaphysical world?

Just because you can't explain it doesn't mean it doesn't exist. Isaac Newton and Albert Einstein themselves questioned the existence of spirit worlds, God, angels and demons, heaven and hell, and many other things that could not and still can not be explained.

People specifically in this thread refuting what I'm saying are literally pretending to know everything. It sounds like a grand claim to make, but they are literally claiming to know everything. Physics and logic are all that exist to Valconoid, he said it clear as day?

You use words such as SEEM and PREDICT, meaning that they are not 100% accurate. Therefore you CAN'T know, you DON'T know. Stop trying to pretend like the world is controllable, it's not.

Where I can believe what I WANT the truth to be? A man knows that what he wants isn't always what matters, but what needs to be. I'm not on here claiming to know anything other than the fact that it is impossible for us to prove much of anything as absolute truth.

I DON'T have to give you a strong reason, you can't refute it.

Science is not 100% accurate, I can say that with a certainty. Would you really say that there has never been an event that happened that could not be explained by science? Not for a lack of knowledge, but literally COULD NOT be measured by the greatest minds in the universe no matter how badly they wanted to? You think things happen randomly? Do we live our lives accidental like and whatever happens happens? Are we existing on a combination of random occurences combined with our own choices? Or are we living in a universe that is dictated by how far you can measure a test tube up your ass?


I think your misunderstood my point.

I am not saying that science is always accurate or anything like this. I clearly stated that anyone saying so is plain stupid. I said its only a frame in which we try to understand the world and for now, its doing a pretty good job. If you doubt that, just look at all the technology around you.

Seriously though, you really did not understood a single word in my post;

I never said that we can explain everything,
I never said science was always right,
A lots of science's predictions are accurate (so I really dont understand how the use of the word ''prediction'' can lead to any kind of inaccuracy),
Yes you have to give me a good reason, cause if you want to play the unfalsifiable hypothesis game, we are going to be here for all eternity with idle talk.

Quote
I'm not on here claiming to know anything other than the fact that it is impossible for us to prove much of anything as absolute truth.


This is, in my opinion, the core of your argument I dont agree with. Plz read on relativism as a knowledge theory (not some kind of moral or aesthetic text, but epistemic ones). As I stated in my first post, lots of your premisses have been the subject of debates over philosophical history, which makes it very hard to be as radical in your relativism.

A beautiful paradox is relativism, isnt it? While claiming the there is no truth we can access, they themselves propose an ultimate, universal and absolute truth, which is that there can be no truth for us. Relativism is hardly a position you can keep when you want to make it a generalized epistemic theory since in its core, it proposed only the truth that fits its speech, which is that there is none.



Go Back To Anime Topic List
Prev1121314
Add Reply New Topic New Poll