hard to say since there different Genres, but for the mystery from this series to the slice of life in Hanasaku Iroha i feel i enjoyed them both equally but i watched them at the same time so it might be different if you watched one then the other l8r on i dunno

Not really comparable.. Just too different to say which is better

she did not die, not nice at all :/

well she wasnt gonna die in the first place, she would just be brain dead until they decide to unplug her xD

either that or Wake up being retarded or something like being crippled from the combo of Drug and her head being bashed in when she hit the ground. lucky she landed on that flower bed which probably absorbed most of the impact, only reason she is probably alive

and a lot of debate
sad
this topics gonna end up like all seasonal anime, serveral pages back

nvm lmao

This post was edited by MelsonX on Sep 27 2011 10:06pm

: O

not completely butchered by j.c.stuff
son, i am impress

So I finally got around to watching this.. ( I know I'm slow and behind the times... )

only going to give it a 7 1/2 out of 10.. I was going to score it lower but the ending was good so..

It seemed rushed, my opinion is it throws you into the main story to fast. It could have benefited a lot from a few more episodes just showing some of Narumi's school life or home life ect.. and maybe the same for some of the other characters.

I feel like the only characters I really got a good understanding of was Alice, Yondaime and Min.. Alice's personality comes through well and you get a good feel for her and the kind of person she is. Plus the fact she is a major contributor in every episode. As for Min and Yondaime they had episodes with back story, so I got a better understanding of what they are all about there. not so much for the main characters Narumi or Ayaka tho..

I am seriously considering picking up the manga for this or at the vary least getting the drama CDs.. I just hope the drama CDs do not just cover what was in the anime, I read on wiki that after Ayaka jumps from the roof she wakes up but has amnesia and there is some story there.. but it seems in the mangas that all takes place before the whole promotion of the band and return of Hirasaka-gumi. so it seems the anime does not fallow the same path as the manga.

/e If anyone has any info on the drama CDs and if they fallow the manga more then the anime that would be extremely helpful

//ee nvm looked it up myself and it seems they just fallow the anime... alas I am forced to read xD

This post was edited by 13lack_Cat on Nov 17 2011 05:23am