I'll take my leave.

This post was edited by Touhou on Nov 11 2011 03:09pm

lew

My last statement was an opinion, to which you called me a fanboy. Yeah, that's a personal attack. I re-read it, just to make sure. Want me to triple check? (PS: I watched all of those shows I listed, I didn't stop less than halfway)

Anyways, the problem with inductive reasoning is that you are all making claims that are MORE than opinions (See: the "masterpiece" argument), and trying to play them off as opinions. That is a problem. Whether or not one piece is a masterpiece, to me, would be an objective claim. Whether or not one piece is a 'good' show (where 'good' must, again, be defined in a general or personal form), I would argue, is also an objective claim. Now whether or not you LIKE it, that's subjective and I don't care.

The problem is instead of people saying they didn't like one piece, they just flat out call it BAD or find 10000 other 'creative' ways to poison the well. (Guess what poisoning the well is...)



Really? I thought I read this earlier..



(I bring this quote up because you said something about America, so I had to question which demographic you were referring to...)

So, we should use the shounen definition of kids? Because that was never explicitly stated, in any argument I've seen thus far. People generalize 'kids' and add an implied negative connotation with it. The shounen 'kid', then, ranges from 10-17 iirc.Because anime/manga are adapted in languages for several different countries, you cannot just say kids and expect me to understand which demographic you refer to. Hardly me being ignorant.





What? These claims are 'generally' factual? I've yet to see a single one proven. These aren't even claims most of the time, they are just mindless attacks upon the integrity of the show. These are subjective misgivings. As far as the %, I have no idea where you are going with that.



what did I contradict?

If 10 million people believe in god, and 100 don't, does it then stand that god exists? Lol? This leads to a shitty argument, IMO.

It does not follow that, just because 10000 people say one piece is not a masterpiece, or 100000 people say that one piece is SHITTY, BAD, NOT WORTH WATCHING, that these claims are true.



Is it? What do you think most animes are based off of? Novels or mangas? Nah, not possible......................

Ok, I'll just pretend to ignore that for now. While I did commit to this analogy, I was trying to make a point: You, and these other folks who are in the same position as you, are judging the show ONE PIECE without having actually completed it to the current episode, let alone the last. Now that's fine if you were just saying you didn't like the show. But people, as I said before, rarely stop there. It's almost always an elitist contest of talking shit or trying to make others not want to watch the show by constantly saying negative things about it. THAT IS MY PROBLEM, OK BRAH?

This post was edited by Eep on Nov 11 2011 03:41pm

Bros... at the end of the day, nobody but you two are gonna be making a big deal out of ABSOLUTELY nothing. This is like trying to make the democrats and republicans come to a reasonable compromise. It won't happen because everybody has their own opinion and for people like me, this shit annoys us. You hate one piece? Ok, keep it to yourself. You like one piece? Good, just don't flaunt it like it's better than everything else.

/END

That is hardly the issue my friend :[

The issue is that people aren't just having an opinion, they are making claims about one piece, claims that I argue are for the sake of trying to get others to NOT watch one piece.

shit just got religious

Eep, I'll get back at your last post later today. Gotta head out.

don't even bother


just read this part

same shit for naruto brah

yeah but Eep doesn't give a shit about naruto

#thirdperson