I don't have any anime reccomendations, but I highly recommend you head over to MyAnimeList, sign up, add what you've seen sofar, and give it ratings. It's easier when you're just starting into anime as a hobby.
For scoring, I highly recommend you first establish a normalized scoring scale. e.g. 10/10 means the anime had "...." or you feel "..." about it. 9 out of 10 means... etc.. It's not good to grade anime against each other, typically.
After you do all that, people can give you more proper anime recommendations.
Example of what you get:
http://myanimelist.net/animelist/GodelThis post was edited by Godel on Dec 3 2013 08:41am