d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Entertainment Room > Anime > Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood
12Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 17,661
Joined: Apr 19 2009
Gold: 119.26
Mar 29 2012 11:14am
Just wtf is this shit



I like this 'remake' but seriously WTF @ this guy
Member
Posts: 17,094
Joined: Oct 16 2008
Gold: 6,669.61
Mar 29 2012 11:28am
He's in the manga so it wouldn't make sense to cut him out when they're making an exact adaption.

I agree that he's a bit annoying but it's not like he's seen much anyway.
Member
Posts: 17,661
Joined: Apr 19 2009
Gold: 119.26
Mar 29 2012 11:44am
Quote (GuZ @ Mar 30 2012 01:28am)
He's in the manga so it wouldn't make sense to cut him out when they're making an exact adaption.

I agree that he's a bit annoying but it's not like he's seen much anyway.


But why is he so gay and why does he have to wear a dress like that lol
Member
Posts: 17,094
Joined: Oct 16 2008
Gold: 6,669.61
Mar 29 2012 11:54am
Quote (JukeBOXX @ Mar 29 2012 07:44pm)
But why is he so gay and why does he have to wear a dress like that lol


Guild: Gay Pride

No idea. Maybe they didn't want Winry to live with some unknown straight macho guy since it implies something unwanted.
Or maybe the mangaka's wife beat him up for not having any sexual diversity in the series and he reluctantly put him in there.
Member
Posts: 17,661
Joined: Apr 19 2009
Gold: 119.26
Mar 29 2012 12:06pm
Quote (GuZ @ Mar 30 2012 01:54am)
Guild: Gay Pride

No idea. Maybe they didn't want Winry to live with some unknown straight macho guy since it implies something unwanted.
Or maybe the mangaka's wife beat him up for not having any sexual diversity in the series and he reluctantly put him in there.


Mm they shoulda made him just a gay guy, but no dress. Or some really nerdy small shrimpy dude obsessed with metal and crap
Member
Posts: 15,035
Joined: Jul 24 2008
Gold: 3,446.77
Mar 29 2012 01:39pm
he's there for humor most animes have some type of cross dressing scene or person in them at some point.

it add's humor that people can laugh at and since a majority of people are straight it doesn't effect to many of the viewers who could get butt hurt over it ( btw I meant butt hurt as insulted)

it's like the boondocks racist jokes are funny as long as black people are saying it. thus the majority of the veiwers won't get butt hurt over it.

I hope I cleared up your questions :)
Member
Posts: 17,661
Joined: Apr 19 2009
Gold: 119.26
Mar 31 2012 10:49am
Quote (Ensane @ Mar 30 2012 03:39am)
he's there for humor most animes have some type of cross dressing scene or person in them at some point.

it add's humor that people can laugh at and since a majority of people are straight it doesn't effect to many of the viewers who could get butt hurt over it ( btw I meant butt hurt as insulted)

it's like the boondocks racist jokes are funny as long as black people are saying it. thus the majority of the veiwers won't get butt hurt over it.

I hope I cleared up your questions :)


I don't see how anyone could get butt hurt over it, I was just like WTF that rather than continue with normal characters they put a completely retarded character in.
Member
Posts: 15,035
Joined: Jul 24 2008
Gold: 3,446.77
Mar 31 2012 11:26am
Quote (JukeBOXX @ Mar 31 2012 11:49am)
I don't see how anyone could get butt hurt over it, I was just like WTF that rather than continue with normal characters they put a completely retarded character in.



it's to bring comic relief I agree he wasn't needed but even shakespear knew the importance of comic relief during multiple sad parts
Member
Posts: 17,661
Joined: Apr 19 2009
Gold: 119.26
Apr 1 2012 10:08am
I am on episode 63, where Ed gets his arm back. Does not make sense. They all stand there doing nothing while the guy is walking towards Ed rather than help him via shooting, alchemy, punches etc then when Ed has his arm back they all just sit back and cheer him on rather than help.

He did not need his arm back, the girl or anyone could of simply used their alchemy or a gun to help him.

After liking the series so much, to have it have this at the end is like finding half a eaten bug in your food, you have enjoyed the meal but then it is spoiled knowing you have eating a bug.

However it was quite emotional after the fight was over. That was a good ending. Still they the above bit does not make sense and slightly spoiled it. Overall still great though.

This post was edited by JukeBOXX on Apr 1 2012 10:28am
Member
Posts: 12,380
Joined: Jun 8 2006
Gold: 2,482.00
Apr 1 2012 01:09pm
winry too sexy
my boo
Go Back To Anime Topic List
12Next
Closed New Topic New Poll