d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Entertainment Room > Anime > So What's Wrong With Dubbing?
1234Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 7,411
Joined: Nov 13 2008
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Warn: 10%
Nov 9 2011 06:51pm
From what I know, the English language has the most words, I mean we have words for almost everything imaginable.

So when we translate things over from Japanese/Chinese to English, we might add/simplify some words.

So if we make it more comprehensible, what's the hate with dubs?

Just looking for opinions and a good discussion.
I love dubs, but I'll watch sub if I've no other option.

This post was edited by kye7 on Nov 9 2011 06:51pm
Member
Posts: 20,232
Joined: May 30 2008
Gold: 24.40
Nov 9 2011 06:53pm
the voice actors chosen are usually terrible.
the voice actors dont match the characters at all usually.

this is (imo) why subbed>dubbed.
Member
Posts: 7,411
Joined: Nov 13 2008
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Warn: 10%
Nov 9 2011 06:55pm
Quote (Marley @ Nov 9 2011 06:53pm)
the voice actors chosen are usually terrible.
the voice actors dont match the characters at all usually.

this is (imo) why subbed>dubbed.


How does a character match a voice?
I can understand see how a grown man's voice in a little kid would be wrong, but I've never seen that.

So far, all the dubs I've seen have been great.

Edit: With ONE exception of Makoto Hyuga from the Rebuild of Evangelion (the original voice actor wouldn't do it)...
UGH.

This post was edited by kye7 on Nov 9 2011 06:55pm
Member
Posts: 15,035
Joined: Jul 24 2008
Gold: 3,446.77
Nov 9 2011 06:56pm
Quote (kye7 @ Nov 9 2011 07:55pm)
How does a character match a voice?
I can understand see how a grown man's voice in a little kid would be wrong, but I've never seen that.

So far, all the dubs I've seen have been great.


im pretty they have a middle aged women playing naruto in the dubbed one

does that make any sense?

I actaully like some dubbed stuff though like dbz,inuyasha
but most animes are better subbed then dubbed imo

This post was edited by Ensane on Nov 9 2011 06:56pm
Member
Posts: 7,847
Joined: Oct 30 2007
Gold: 405.00
Nov 9 2011 06:56pm
Miss translations still happen.
But mostly all the hate on dubs is the voices which most people who watch subs don't know Japanese so I don't understand them.

Anyways I watch both subs and dubs both are good for me. Even if I watch it dubbed tho I turned the subs on just a habit after watching soo many subs.
Member
Posts: 7,411
Joined: Nov 13 2008
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Warn: 10%
Nov 9 2011 06:57pm
Quote (Ensane @ Nov 9 2011 06:56pm)
im pretty they have a middle aged women playing naruto in the dubbed one

does that make any sense?


I know that's a fact, and IMO she does a great job.

You know what I mean when I say a grown black man's voice in a little kid, it's not the same.
Member
Posts: 20,232
Joined: May 30 2008
Gold: 24.40
Nov 9 2011 07:01pm
Quote (kye7 @ Nov 10 2011 12:55am)
How does a character match a voice?
I can understand see how a grown man's voice in a little kid would be wrong, but I've never seen that.

So far, all the dubs I've seen have been great.

Edit: With ONE exception of Makoto Hyuga from the Rebuild of Evangelion (the original voice actor wouldn't do it)...
UGH.


watch a subbed anime and u can tell that usually a specific voice actor was chosen for the part.
watch the same one dubbed and it sounds like they just picked some random person with no experience.
Member
Posts: 7,411
Joined: Nov 13 2008
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Warn: 10%
Nov 9 2011 07:02pm
Quote (Marley @ Nov 9 2011 07:01pm)
watch a subbed anime and u can tell that usually a specific voice actor was chosen for the part.
watch the same one dubbed and it sounds like they just picked some random person with no experience.


Funimation does alot of the dubbing, and I like them
I really don't think they pick a random person, and they choose specific people.

While some actors do A LOT of voices, they still match fine to me.
Watching Berserk now, nothing seems out of place IMO
Member
Posts: 7,847
Joined: Oct 30 2007
Gold: 405.00
Nov 9 2011 07:03pm
I have to say tho there are a lot of really good dubs out there and compared to years ago they are way better than before.

Some of my favorite dubs:
Cowboy Bebop
Great Teacher Onizuka
Code Geass
Member
Posts: 26,802
Joined: Aug 14 2006
Gold: 15.00
Nov 9 2011 07:05pm
prolly cuz 70% of the male voices are ichigos seyiuu
Go Back To Anime Topic List
1234Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll