pls help friends, i cant decide

fellowship is the only watchable one, imo

say waaaaaaat.


All 3 is great. The second one is the best imo.


Answer to topic creator: Watch all 3, start with the first.

Maybe if you're a huge fan of the books to begin with, but otherwise I really only think the first one is watchable. And don't watch the extended versions, again... unless you're a huuuuge fan of the books, otherwise it's just boring as shit.

i am a huge fan of the books
but i dont have the extended version and havent watched them yet either

Return of the Jedi

Can't handle dialogue.....?

I wish each movie was twice as long and I still wouldn't get bored.

I can't handle useless lore-crap that does nothing to enhance the movie. I can understand how a fan of the books would love as much crap packed into the film as possible. I'm judging the films as films, not as adaptions.

give specific examples of useless lore crap

Damn, it's been very long. I've only seen both the theatrical and extended of Fellowship. The other two I only saw extended. Pretty much all those dream-like scenes with Aragorn and Arwen and stuff like that.