Both movies pulled me in. I think what notched Fury over American Sniper in my mind was the propaganda and the inaccuracies ( all 'based on a true story' has them granted) but more of the propaganda for sure. That always leaves a sour taste in my mouth lol.
I was more pulled into Fury and i'm most likely bias as I said propoganda, but WWII is always my favorite setting for a war movie and the tank was something new to me.