d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Entertainment Room > Movies & TV Shows > Shows Like Survivor Man > Iso Info
123Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 8,550
Joined: Apr 1 2012
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Warn: 20%
Jul 1 2013 06:39pm
I just watched all of the survivor man shows, pretty cool tbh..

any other shows like his where a person survives in the wild or where with limited supplies for a week?

thanks!!!
Member
Posts: 1,739
Joined: Jan 31 2009
Gold: 22.05
Jul 1 2013 06:59pm
Man vs. Wild
Member
Posts: 96,330
Joined: Nov 25 2006
Gold: 7.78
Jul 1 2013 07:36pm
man vs wild

dual-survival

Member
Posts: 32,985
Joined: Mar 17 2005
Gold: 6.00
Jul 1 2013 10:52pm
nope.

sadly he was the only one with the balls to do this for real and not just simulate it like the rest.
Member
Posts: 29,218
Joined: Nov 15 2010
Gold: 7.69
Jul 1 2013 11:29pm
Naked and Afraid just started, 2 episodes in.
Member
Posts: 32,985
Joined: Mar 17 2005
Gold: 6.00
Jul 2 2013 06:24am
Quote (BebebBurns @ Jul 2 2013 12:29am)
Naked and Afraid just started, 2 episodes in.


pre-cut trails
drama filled dialogue
nudity as a gimmick rather than a lesson
crew to keep them out of any real danger

i don't see how you call it similar to survivorman when he is alone, informative, risking his life for real.

naked and afraid is just shock factor reality tv just like man vs wild. do weird things so people watch instead of people watching because they enjoy the actual survival part of it.
Member
Posts: 29,218
Joined: Nov 15 2010
Gold: 7.69
Jul 2 2013 07:45am
Quote (Subwoofer @ Jul 2 2013 02:24pm)
pre-cut trails
drama filled dialogue
nudity as a gimmick rather than a lesson
crew to keep them out of any real danger

i don't see how you call it similar to survivorman when he is alone, informative, risking his life for real.

naked and afraid is just shock factor reality tv just like man vs wild. do weird things so people watch instead of people watching because they enjoy the actual survival part of it.


Care to elaborate why it is more gimmic than a lesson and how it could have been a lesson.
Haven't seen survivor man and naked and afraid seems social pornish, maybe a bit dumned down populistic portrayal of the stuff, but if you don't think you can call it ontopic, similar to ops "any other shows like his where a person survives in the wild or where with limited supplies for a week?" question, then you have some issues.
Member
Posts: 32,985
Joined: Mar 17 2005
Gold: 6.00
Jul 2 2013 08:07am
Quote (BebebBurns @ Jul 2 2013 08:45am)
Care to elaborate why it is more gimmic than a lesson and how it could have been a lesson.
Haven't seen survivor man and naked and afraid seems social pornish, maybe a bit dumned down populistic portrayal of the stuff, but if you don't think you can call it ontopic, similar to ops "any other shows like his where a person survives in the wild or where with limited supplies for a week?" question, then you have some issues.


the first episode they didn't try to make clothes, shoes etc. to be honest the people in the first episode would of died if it wasn't for the time limitation because they were terrible at it.

in the first episode they made some very very cosmetic clothes with leaves that served no real function other than to cover up their private areas. insulation and protection are the main qualities you want in clothes...not just to cover up your genitals/boobs.

i still wouldn't call what they do "surviving" it's more like running out the clock just before they would of actually died. the first episode was little more than an example of how to prolong your death....or at time how to make it shorter and far more painful. going after than venomous snake for a meal without calling the girl over to help was just plain foolish. the method he used to kill it was also foolish. he put himself within striking distance of the snake instead of just going and getting a 10lb rock and throwing it on top of it from a distance.

if you enjoy survivorman then naked and afraid isn't something you would enjoy watching most likely because you'll see far more mistakes and stupidity than you do real survival knowledge.
Member
Posts: 55,688
Joined: Jun 8 2006
Gold: 7.00
Jul 2 2013 08:43am
grylls still do crazy things.
Member
Posts: 51,682
Joined: Jul 27 2007
Gold: 0.90
Jul 2 2013 09:39am
Survivorman is unique, haven't seen anything like it yet.

Other shows always have a crew, Grylls (man vs. wild) has a crew so it isn't totally real, but he does provide some very good survival techniques (not urine drinking..).

This post was edited by Meatstick on Jul 2 2013 09:40am
Go Back To Movies & TV Shows Topic List
123Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll