Can't really call WC3 a flop because it pretty much invented League of Legends and Dota 2.

ive read the book and it had different mood, still mysterious fairytale like. hobbit movies were cartoonish without depth
3rd movie was best of the three

lolz

still not a decent movie but truth

? i just found the third one to be the weakest, surprised it's the best for you especially if you've read the books

i liked the first one the most btw, after watching it thought it was as good as lotr, less so in hindsight but each one after seemed to flow less well that the previous and wasn't as classic somehow

well ye its not the truth
but since i didnt care for adaption of first to films it was more entertaining crap
firat was meh-pretty bad to me dunno was it bcause of that high fps gimmick but it looked really fake and like high budget tv soap opera
series was pale caricatyre of book and fe one of my fave scene in book when child: stoned trolls were just goofy
from second movie that barrel in river scene was really stupid

liked lotr tho but been a while since saw em

Yeah it was one of the first books i read properly/remember as a kid but i still recognized when stuff was't from the books. Like the hobbits fighting smaug in an enclosed space was ridiculous, and half of the third film, like the eagle turning up and making anything that had happened in the battle upto that point meaningless, and those tunneling things and duel on frozen lake at the end.

They should have just made two movies and had the hobbits be a bit less invincible, i liked the bit in goblins dungeon when they're moving along but it was pretty ott, but barrel scene was just way too much. I liked the flowing action but they needed to turn it down a lot and make everything not quite so convenient.

Anyway would have been perfect for the books then but people would still complain because it isn't as dark/serious as lotr.

Not too mention the fact that the main antagonist, the white Orc...isn't a real character in the Hobbit book. Nor was legolas or the other female elf. Along with half the movies lol

I nulled voted... you ask why... well it is basically a stupid poll... how the fuck can you compare a game to a movie that was produced from a book that was written and given notoriety [spelling].
Basically you can't, so the poll if fucking stupid.

Now... why not make the poll based on another game like Final Fantasy vs Warcraft... graphics, storyline and everything else? You can't... then stop posting opposing polls that don't have anything in comparison.

pretty much implied