d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Entertainment Room > Movies & TV Shows > Star Wars Epsode 8 Speculation
Prev14567Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 42,338
Joined: Apr 10 2006
Gold: 4,396.17
Dec 24 2015 02:40pm
Anakin was good with Droid and piloting. Luke was good with fixing technology and droids.

Rey is good with droids, piloting, and fixing technology.

There is a possibility that kylo and Rey are twins, but with the way the story has played out so far, it seems more likely they will have her as Luke's daughter.
Member
Posts: 11,960
Joined: Aug 4 2008
Gold: 0.80
Dec 24 2015 04:13pm
Quote (Blah58 @ Dec 24 2015 07:03pm)
Ani only matters if Rey is Luke's daughter as it offers an explination for her tech prowess, if she is hans daughter than han could be the reason.


Luke and leia are twins though?
Member
Posts: 39,673
Joined: Jun 17 2006
Gold: 5,920.00
Dec 24 2015 04:43pm
Quote (WelSh @ Dec 24 2015 04:13pm)
Luke and leia are twins though?


And? Why does that matter with the point I was making?
Member
Posts: 43,761
Joined: Aug 27 2009
Gold: 63,142.89
Dec 24 2015 07:46pm
Quote (Blah58 @ Dec 24 2015 05:43pm)
And? Why does that matter with the point I was making?


because

your statement "Ani only matters if Rey is Luke's daughter" is not true because her connection to Anakin is identical in either scenario .. she's still his granddaughter either way.

This post was edited by kayeto on Dec 24 2015 07:46pm
Member
Posts: 11,960
Joined: Aug 4 2008
Gold: 0.80
Dec 24 2015 07:54pm
Quote (kayeto @ Dec 25 2015 01:46am)
because

your statement "Ani only matters if Rey is Luke's daughter" is not true because her connection to Anakin is identical in either scenario .. she's still his granddaughter either way.


Thank you
Member
Posts: 39,673
Joined: Jun 17 2006
Gold: 5,920.00
Dec 24 2015 08:24pm
Quote (kayeto @ Dec 24 2015 07:46pm)
because

your statement "Ani only matters if Rey is Luke's daughter" is not true because her connection to Anakin is identical in either scenario .. she's still his granddaughter either way.


Yeah but once again it doesn't matter unless Luke is the father. Ani being her grandfather is a way to explain her technological prowess (the cockpit scene with han). If Leia and Han are her parents than Ani is irrelevant because the cockpit scene can be explained as a father/daughter thing.

My entire point is that scene has a second explanation, most people are using it as proof she is Hans daughter.
Member
Posts: 41,240
Joined: Apr 14 2006
Gold: 5,621.71
Dec 24 2015 08:35pm
Quote (Blah58 @ Dec 24 2015 09:24pm)
Yeah but once again it doesn't matter unless Luke is the father. Ani being her grandfather is a way to explain her technological prowess (the cockpit scene with han). If Leia and Han are her parents than Ani is irrelevant because the cockpit scene can be explained as a father/daughter thing.

My entire point is that scene has a second explanation, most people are using it as proof she is Hans daughter.


Not most people. Consenus is fairly split but I think looking at everything there is more to suggest Skywalker lineage. Ik I'm not alone too =]
Member
Posts: 11,960
Joined: Aug 4 2008
Gold: 0.80
Dec 24 2015 09:27pm
Holy shit she's a skywalker whether she's lukes or Han's daughter
Member
Posts: 43,761
Joined: Aug 27 2009
Gold: 63,142.89
Dec 24 2015 09:51pm
Quote (Blah58 @ Dec 24 2015 09:24pm)
Yeah but once again it doesn't matter unless Luke is the father. Ani being her grandfather is a way to explain her technological prowess (the cockpit scene with han). If Leia and Han are her parents than Ani is irrelevant because the cockpit scene can be explained as a father/daughter thing.

My entire point is that scene has a second explanation, most people are using it as proof she is Hans daughter.


The reason that people would use the cockpit scene as evidence she is Han's daughter is because she kept saying the same things that he was saying at the same time. It's the similarity in how they think. Whether she had gained "technological prowess" from Anakin or Salacious Crumb doesn't have any bearing on that.

There are 2 conclusions we could draw from that scene:
1) The fact Rey and Han were saying the same lines means they have a connection OR
2) The fact they were saying the same lines was not significant and we should not think that it will end up meaning something big later on.

This post was edited by kayeto on Dec 24 2015 09:52pm
Member
Posts: 39,673
Joined: Jun 17 2006
Gold: 5,920.00
Dec 24 2015 10:26pm
Quote (kayeto @ Dec 24 2015 09:51pm)
The reason that people would use the cockpit scene as evidence she is Han's daughter is because she kept saying the same things that he was saying at the same time. It's the similarity in how they think. Whether she had gained "technological prowess" from Anakin or Salacious Crumb doesn't have any bearing on that.

There are 2 conclusions we could draw from that scene:
1) The fact Rey and Han were saying the same lines means they have a connection OR
2) The fact they were saying the same lines was not significant and we should not think that it will end up meaning something big later on.


No, it means she knows what she is talking about. Essentially what was happening is they were both saying factual things, because they both knew what they were talking about.

We essentially have 3 options:
1) she is hans daughter and the scene hints at it.
2) she is lukes daughter and the scene is explained by ani being her grandfather + luke and hans friendship seems to have extended to lukes daughter.
3) random parents, scene is now random and awkward.

This post was edited by Blah58 on Dec 24 2015 10:26pm
Go Back To Movies & TV Shows Topic List
Prev14567Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll