d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Entertainment Room > Movies & TV Shows > Game Of Thrones Season 5
Prev1444546474862Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 3,333
Joined: Mar 15 2007
Gold: 0.00
Jun 9 2015 05:08am
arya tok a lucky turn,
dont think she'l be able to kill that guy
Member
Posts: 40,183
Joined: Apr 29 2006
Gold: 20,826.51
Jun 9 2015 07:35am
Quote (kayeto @ Jun 9 2015 09:57pm)
My memory may be failing me, but I can't think of an instance from the books where it talks about a dragon from having been killed in battle by enemy soldiers throughout the history of Westeros. The way that dragons are spoken of, they are pretty much regarded as the medieval equivalent of nuclear weapons.

I'm not saying the show is factually incorrect or that I disagree with their decision to portray Drogon like that. I thought the scene was adapted just fine. It did however, deviate from the spirit of what dragons represent in peoples' minds.


You read the books, I haven't, but in that episode, the girl was reading a book about a person trying to kill a dragon by hiding behind a mirror sheen shield, he did fail that attempt and die, is that also in the
books you read discussing the history of Westeros? Does the book state how the Dragons died? Was it in battle of Winter, before the Wall was built to protect against the Nightwalkers [or whatever they are called]?
Or, did the Dragons start dying off when Khalessi's race were dying off?

Don't really reply to those questions as a post, just think on it for yourself and that goes for other readers that have read the books.
__________________

Comparing Harry Potter dragons to GoT dragons is irrelevent. I personally liked the looks of the dragon in GoT, and how they showed it running to pick up speed using its' wings for momentum was pretty good,
whereas most other dragons in 99% of other shows can just flap their wings and up they go.
Member
Posts: 35,236
Joined: Sep 4 2007
Gold: 80.00
Jun 9 2015 07:44am
Quote (izParagonzi @ 9 Jun 2015 09:35)
You read the books, I haven't, but in that episode, the girl was reading a book about a person trying to kill a dragon by hiding behind a mirror sheen shield, he did fail that attempt and die, is that also in the
books you read discussing the history of Westeros? Does the book state how the Dragons died? Was it in battle of Winter, before the Wall was built to protect against the Nightwalkers [or whatever they are called]?
Or, did the Dragons start dying off when Khalessi's race were dying off?

Don't really reply to those questions as a post, just think on it for yourself and that goes for other readers that have read the books.
__________________

Comparing Harry Potter dragons to GoT dragons is irrelevent. I personally liked the looks of the dragon in GoT, and how they showed it running to pick up speed using its' wings for momentum was pretty good,
whereas most other dragons in 99% of other shows can just flap their wings and up they go.


I agree the dragons actually looked like they had some weight to get going for flight.
Member
Posts: 43,761
Joined: Aug 27 2009
Gold: 63,142.89
Jun 9 2015 08:12am
Quote (izParagonzi @ Jun 9 2015 08:35am)
Don't really reply to those questions as a post, just think on it for yourself and that goes for other readers that have read the books.


Those were the questions I thought about before I made my post. That's why I said "I'm not saying the show is factually incorrect". I'm sure the dragons are mortal, organic creatures.

dakariii painted an accurate picture of the way that dragons are viewed by people in Westeros. They did successfully assault the largest castle in history by burning the towers.
Member
Posts: 63,058
Joined: Jul 15 2005
Gold: 152.00
Jun 9 2015 08:50am
Quote (kayeto @ Jun 9 2015 10:12am)
Those were the questions I thought about before I made my post. That's why I said "I'm not saying the show is factually incorrect". I'm sure the dragons are mortal, organic creatures.

dakariii painted an accurate picture of the way that dragons are viewed by people in Westeros. They did successfully assault the largest castle in history by burning the towers.


The dragons are still babies right? I imagine that's why they aren't impenetrable juggernauts yet.
Member
Posts: 21,087
Joined: Jun 11 2008
Gold: 1,030.00
Jun 9 2015 09:10am
Quote (Voyaging @ Jun 9 2015 09:50am)
The dragons are still babies right? I imagine that's why they aren't impenetrable juggernauts yet.


Maybe not babies but still young. I think as of the last book (ADWD), Drogon's wings stretch 20 ft.
He's bigger in the show I think.
Member
Posts: 57,755
Joined: Mar 7 2006
Gold: 0.00
Jun 9 2015 09:40am
:rofl:

Member
Posts: 43,761
Joined: Aug 27 2009
Gold: 63,142.89
Jun 9 2015 09:47am
Quote (Voyaging @ Jun 9 2015 09:50am)
The dragons are still babies right? I imagine that's why they aren't impenetrable juggernauts yet.


No, we can't say that's right. The show doesn't provide enough info to make that conclusion. There is a difference between the Drogon we saw this week and the way I seem to remember his size and "combat power" being described during that scene in the book.

I'm not saying I didn't like the way that scene was done. I'm simply weighing in on the discussion about how the dragons we see are going to stack up to what other types of dragons there have been in other stories.

This post was edited by kayeto on Jun 9 2015 09:47am
Member
Posts: 63,058
Joined: Jul 15 2005
Gold: 152.00
Jun 9 2015 10:16am
Quote (kayeto @ Jun 9 2015 11:47am)
No, we can't say that's right. The show doesn't provide enough info to make that conclusion. There is a difference between the Drogon we saw this week and the way I seem to remember his size and "combat power" being described during that scene in the book.

I'm not saying I didn't like the way that scene was done. I'm simply weighing in on the discussion about how the dragons we see are going to stack up to what other types of dragons there have been in other stories.


Official rendering of Aegon on Balerion:

Member
Posts: 6,511
Joined: Aug 20 2007
Gold: 0.00
Jun 9 2015 11:32am
one dragon dies before the end of this season, also another stalk dies.
Go Back To Movies & TV Shows Topic List
Prev1444546474862Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll