Quote (Bazi @ Apr 3 2015 01:25am)
Your interpretation is what I was implying ( if I'm following you correctly)...that Lori was the catalyst for Shane's impulsive plan to kill rick by admitting to her own mixed feelings
Quote (kayeto @ Apr 3 2015 02:24am)
I would say that calling her the 'catalyst' is too strong a word for it, but she was sort of an enabler.
First of all, it didn't take very long after hearing Rick was dead for her to open her legs and let Shane deposit his seed inside her womb. We didn't see exactly how things progressed between them, so I'm sort of just filling in the blanks with my best guess. Regardless what happens after that, she kind of has some responsibility for the way Shane feels towards her.
Secondly, the impression she's putting out to Shane is that if, by chance, Rick were to get bit by a random zombie at any time, she'd go right back to being all over him. She's almost keeping him on the back burner by acting like Rick being alive is the only thing keeping them apart. Doing this to an aggressive type guy at a time when things are crazy does not exactly calm the situation.
I honestly think that Lori wasn't sure who was better for her and Carl, but choosing Rick was just the easier, more natural choice. If you boil it down to primal human instinct, letting Rick and Shane fight to the death is actually a logical fair solution.
Quote (Bazi @ Apr 3 2015 07:08am)
If Lori wasnt there, it wouldn't have happened. If Lori didn't say the things she said, when she said them, I have my doubts Shane would have acted as he did, at the time he did. I would go as far to say "catalyst" is too meek a word to describe Lori's effect on the dynamic.
Anyway you are entitled to your own view too :)
The funny thing you guys are really missing... season 1 where Shane had his rifle aimed at Rick and held it there. Shane had the intentions there and then, before the mention of Lori being pregnant or before season 2 episode 12. As far as Lori was concerned, Rick was dead, by Shanes' own words... Rick was not coming back, and she felt greatful for Shanes' help... so she slept with him, she wasn't doing anything wrong, she probably thought that being with Shane was in a way being with Rick, since those two were great friends. Remember, she always loved Rick, even in season one, removing her necklace was out of respect and also hard for her.