You dumb? I never said things like this cant happen to hot girls...it can happen to EVERYONE.

First, you know this show is fake/scripted.
2nd, you know she isn't dead irl
3rd, if you ever built a show about suicide, the posterchild of the movie would be some average girl or ugly girl or an obese girl not a freaking hot babe that in EVERY school would be the top girl of the school with more friends than anyone
4th, if girl was average at best, it'd DEFINATLY helped make you feel more bad for her to help the storyline they tried to show

NOT realistic in THAT aspect,
you think because I say shes good looking that automatically means It cant happen or that I automatically stop caring...and thats where you're wrong
That's like saying...ok im gonna build a movie about respect and the freaking main actor is gonna be oussama ben laden


Reverse the roles, lets say you build a story about bullying and the guy wants to suicide and hes this 6"5 270 pounds good looking muscular dude who gets all the chicks
how fucking realistic is it?

you'd fucking take a nerd for that role in the movie but instead they brought a hot girl for the views because they know hot girls in shows or movies = views even if they're terrible actors
you see that shit all the time

Again, this shit has nothing to do with genders. and you're trying too hard to go away from what i've said, this isnt even my main complaint with the show

Her reactions and how she handled situations were terrible.



------------
In this end I enjoyed this show for what it is and tried to accomplish but it failed in making you sympathize with some characters in the first 9 episodes and that's what the show missed for what it was trying to do all along.
Even clay for fuck sakes didn't cry listening to those tapes until he hear his own tape (past 9 episodes)
When they announced she killed herself, pretty sure fucking clay didn't even cry he was emotionless like I was watching the show (and we didnt even know he loved her and if he did his first reaction would of been to cry like any normal human being) then if u saw him cried, you'd felt legit sympathy for him

There was nothing to make you feel sad in this movie in the first 9 episodes to the point where u have to hold back tears which was what the whole show should of been about
If I ever built a movie about suicide, my main goal is to bring out emotions out of people....and that would start by casting the main girl being an average looking girl to meet realistic standards of every days life and then I'd make you sympathize with every characters as much as I can

Show is good, masterpiece? hell no, could of been but failed.

This post was edited by Nevada on Apr 12 2017 09:42pm

hannah baker was a slut and got what she deserved

Attractive girls have feelings too.



.....your entire argument is invalid.

This little game your playing that Hannah should have been less attractive is really showing how little you understand about the social messages in this show, along with the gender social problems in reality.

have you seen the perks of being a wallflower and did you like it?

Who are you asking?

It was a solid movie, but depressing.

i thought i quoted nevada lol i guess not. i thought it was a well made movie.. just speaking in terms of how to deliver a movie but i dont know why those movies just feel so tasteless to me and was wondering if he feels the same way about that movie and this tvshow or if he doesnt see any comparison at all.

Well his main problem is not understanding common social issues and the impact they have on people's lives.

Couldn't handle how corny it was. Lasted three episodes somehow. They tried to make it way over dramatic that it's not believable.

So does it get better or does it go further down hill

The thing is, it's not over dramatized because the social issues that occur within the show happen in real life. Dumbing them down wouldn't get the point across. I am from a more sheltered town and I know that these issues are very real and can happen anywhere.

For me, I thought the show did a fine job conveying the messages of very common social issues that are hurting both male and females in an academic atmospshere. These issues even exist well beyond the academic atmosphere.

Well Issues such as lying about hooking up etc may be more realistic. but what I can't handle is like Tony's character and how they are all freaking out about the tapes. It's tv so they had to amplify everything.