d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Entertainment Room > Movies & TV Shows > Harry Potter Series > Ffs
Prev123
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 28,849
Joined: Mar 8 2010
Gold: 2,570.91
Feb 28 2013 06:00am
Quote (Diggins @ Feb 28 2013 07:02am)
for them to do an honest portrayal they would need 16 films.

2 for each 1-5, 3 for 6 3 for 7.

all 2-3 hours long, there are just SO many things that happen in the books, it's literally impossible to change them.

also, they need to fix all the shit they changed, like not letting dobby do any of the great things that happen in the books (they give the credit to meaningless characters). One of the strongest points of the ENTIRE series is dobby's death, and it is shit in the movies because you don't know how much dobby truly helped harry out.

also, they made all dark wizards able to fly in book 6, although, it was the main thing that set voldermort ahead of ALL other wizards, he was so torn/so evil he could actually fly, and he was the ONLY one.


tbh, I never liked Dobby in the books either... wasn't too fond of Dumbledore either lol

the death of Sirius was bs though :angry:
Member
Posts: 66,913
Joined: Oct 23 2007
Gold: 0.01
Feb 28 2013 08:03am
Quote (zarkadon @ 28 Feb 2013 07:00)
tbh, I never liked Dobby in the books either... wasn't too fond of Dumbledore either lol

the death of Sirius was bs though :angry:


dumbledore was kind of a dick, but dobby played the most important role in the books from someone that wasn't a main character.
Member
Posts: 9,230
Joined: Jun 13 2007
Gold: 83.37
Mar 1 2013 07:41am
Quote (Diggins @ 28 Feb 2013 08:02)
for them to do an honest portrayal they would need 16 films.

2 for each 1-5, 3 for 6 3 for 7.

all 2-3 hours long, there are just SO many things that happen in the books, it's literally impossible to change them.

also, they need to fix all the shit they changed, like not letting dobby do any of the great things that happen in the books (they give the credit to meaningless characters). One of the strongest points of the ENTIRE series is dobby's death, and it is shit in the movies because you don't know how much dobby truly helped harry out.

also, they made all dark wizards able to fly in book 6, although, it was the main thing that set voldermort ahead of ALL other wizards, he was so torn/so evil he could actually fly, and he was the ONLY one.


Making a film to close to the source-book isn't a good idea at all.
You can see the result of that in movie 1.
As a series however it could work.
Go Back To Movies & TV Shows Topic List
Prev123
Add Reply New Topic New Poll