I would enjoy seeing this... Almost makes me wanna read the comics just hearing about it.

It is a pretty fucked up part, unfortunately he lives and they all come to regret it..

I hope carl dies

That's random...I assume you're on season 2 still.

He's about as valuable of a character as his mother was. I wouldn't mind seeing him die either. would be interesting.

I don't think this show has the balls to show that though. At most he would probably just go missing and show up as a zombie like Sophia.

He's gained a lot of value in season 3...especially with the dwindling group numbers.

I guess I disagree...

Lost two expendable members that I can think of off hand recently? The black guy and Lori. Which were equally replaced with that other black guy and his white prisoner friend.

This post was edited by Kevorkian on Nov 14 2012 02:14am

Carl's actions saved Hershel's life. Had he not went to get the bandages (on his own, killed walkers no less), the amputation would've killed him.
He isn't the same kid he was in season 2.

Not quite what I meant... Simply saying I think the show could go on without him easily. If not be better because of it.

I dunno, ever since Lori died, I don't have as big a problem with Carl.