Quote (SBD @ Sep 23 2022 11:40am)
Honestly the show is fine. Good scenery, decent soundtrack at times. Acting and story so far is mediocre. I couldn't care less about the source material, despite being a fan. I just want a good show. I would not call this show great, I'd just call it fine , but has the chance to develop into something great.
my hope is that the entire season 1 is just build up. GoT did that very well for S1. set the scene, introduce the characters and their motivations, create a general sense of mystery around some characters, then end the season with a what the fuck just happened ball drop. preferably on the very last scene of the very last episode. no preview at all of s2 to follow.
they've got that more or less thusfar. galadriels actions dont matter as much now than showing who she is. elrond same. harfeet same. show who they are and not with much care for if it fits the later lore.
once the war in earnest starts to happen that's when the shit really starts to matter lore wise. because we've seen it on screen in lotr. what isildur does matters a LOT after sauron falls. what elrond does in the war matters. this now is just filler.
does it fit? no. can they make this fit with what matters in the cannon? yes. who gets rings, how those rings were made, how they mobilize vs sauron, etc. all of that can fit with what we have now.