Which doesn't mean anything. She's adopted. And her adoptive father had a secret to share that Red didn't want him to.
Plus moments after she asked him, he deflected after saying no by bringing up her husband which completely changed the direction of the conversation.
Chances are that she is is daughter and he gave her up to protect her because if you remember, red explained that the rest of his family was slaughtered.

This is what keeps it a guessing game... he was either being truthful by saying NO, or misleading and changing the subject matter to keep her safe [either from interrogation or a different truth altogether]
He could be her Uncle... her fathers brother... and yes, he could also be her father, only time will tell.

I wonder if someone is going to make up a "Betting Pool" on whether he is the father or not...

well ofc hes not going to come out and say it...that would ruin it all :/

I think that's how they will end the season

and idk I'm kind of leaning towards red being her father, at the end of the episode it seemed like she came to that realization

e/ and about her keeping her act up with the husband, I think that before he can find out or notice anything different she will end up confronting him

This post was edited by Flameyes on Mar 26 2014 05:35pm

So... if someone told you that the sky is Green, you will believe that?... NO... because you have already acknowledged from others that it is Blue... RIGHT???



Yes... leaning towards Red being the Father, now... as stated before, her father could be Reds brother or something else... very misleading, this is why I like the show... makes you think more.

Lol how do you even consider this to being close to the same thing?

I have NO clue... you believe from the series and the statement from Red that HE is NOT the father... so... you really believe what HE has said?

Honestly.. you do have a brian and can see that some things are misleading... It is true [proof], It COULD be true [innuendo], ETC.

EDIT: If I told you that I was "espanic with african heritage", you will take my word right? ... NOW... if I told you that I found out that I was "espanic with african heritage, BUT, I was born in Tahiti", you will re - evaluate things... RIGHT!!!... basically... what you see is not the real truth, and if you can not think... yes THINK outside the box, YOU will NOT comprehend another persons perception.

MISLEAD

This post was edited by izParagonzi on Mar 27 2014 01:13am

In your own mind, do you sound smart to yourself? Or have you realized how dim-witted you are?

Your interpretation makes your sentence [questioning] obsolete... do you need me to give you a reason, or do you actually know what you are trying
to say? I am not going to assume your question... WHY?... it is simple reallly... if you can not decypher this, then you should not answer it.

there is way too much philosophy going on in here