d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Entertainment Room > Movies & TV Shows > Solo: A Star Wars Story
Prev1101112131416Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 43,761
Joined: Aug 27 2009
Gold: 63,142.89
May 28 2018 04:38pm
Quote (Blah58 @ May 28 2018 05:57pm)
Like I said, you can create movies about social issues but that doesn't mean the message has an impact outside of the actual world of the movie.

Yes 100 years ago things were different, but now it's not 100 years ago. Things have changed, people have changed. I want to be on your side, I want to say that a movie with a good well done political message... like anti-racism, could have an actual effect on people, but the truth is it doesn't, so getting angry over someone putting their own beliefs into a movie is just absurd at this point in time. Plus your entire argument is based on the idea that everyone in Hollywood pushes some political agenda in everything they do, which I think it's total bullshit.


https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2016/08/10-movies-that-changed-the-world/
Quote
In 2015, SeaWorld announced it was ending its controversial “Shamu Show” and replacing it with an “all-new orca experience” to focus on the “natural behaviour of whales”. Although they didn’t say as much, their decision was almost certainly a result of the public outcry created by the 2013 documentary Blackfish.

Quote
A few weeks after the film was released, McDonald’s ditched its super size option and started introducing healthier items to its menus, although they deny this was in response to the documentary.


These cherrypicked, concrete examples illustrate the point clearly. But the same concept can exist to a lesser degree, like slipping some social issues into an otherwise-harmless blockbuster fiction movie, knowing that the ideas will get absorbed subtly.

Quote (Blah58 @ May 28 2018 05:57pm)
I didn't say it is hypocritical to think they both should be allowed, I said it is hypocritical to say that political messages in movies (/video games) have an impact and then turn around and say that violence doesn't have an impact in the same mediums. You can't pick and choose what aspects of something is impactful, either it is, and all of it is, or it isn't, and none of it isn't.


Yes, everything people see impacts them. The more someone is exposed to, the more they absorb. Jams Bond mowing down unnamed Russian henchmen impacts it. Kids shooting Nazis and Demons in DOOM has an impact.

Exposing people to some violent ideas allows them to be able to learn when violence is the right answer and when it is the wrong answer. Currently, I am seeing way too much pacifist propaganda that is creating a generation of pussies that will always follow authority and never stand up for themselves. Luckily we have some pro-violent ideas out there to offset that. Many violent movies take it to far, but there are also some good ones that address the right balance (Walking Dead, Cobra Kai). The movies Prisoners (jackman) was another good one actually. Although there was violence in it (responsible adult father was literally torturing a retarded kid, very tough to watch) it was presented within the context of meaningful ideas.

This post was edited by Kayeto on May 28 2018 04:54pm
Member
Posts: 39,673
Joined: Jun 17 2006
Gold: 5,920.00
May 28 2018 04:56pm
Quote (Kayeto @ May 28 2018 03:38pm)
https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2016/08/10-movies-that-changed-the-world/



These cherrypicked, concrete examples illustrate the point clearly. But the same concept can exist to a lesser degree, like slipping some social issues into an otherwise-harmless blockbuster fiction movie, knowing that the ideas will get absorbed subtly.


I'm sorry, I thought you understood the difference between a fictional movie and a documentary.

I am specifically talking about Hollywood films, not documentaries, hence me limiting my wording to constantly say Hollywood.
Member
Posts: 41,780
Joined: Jan 13 2009
Gold: 25.20
May 28 2018 05:23pm
Quote (Kayeto @ May 28 2018 12:15pm)
ok then..

so since Hilary Clinton is not my health care provider, then health care is not a political issue right? The nurse who is taking my blood pressure is probably not a political activist who knows everything about the obamacare debate, she's just doing her job.


What does that have to do with movies?

Quote (Kayeto @ May 28 2018 02:40pm)
no, health care is a political issue because politics impacts who gets to go see which doctors and the type of care they receive when they go there

just like Hollywood being politicized affects the content of the movies (the characters and plot)


Tom Cruise is a Scientologist but that doesn't stop me from loving his movies.
You need to be able to separate your opinion of a person from your opinion of their work.

I don't care if a movie is made by a collaboration of Hitler, Stalin, Donald Trump, Satan, and the monster from IT.
If it's a good movie, I'll like the movie.

This post was edited by FroggyG on May 28 2018 05:26pm
Member
Posts: 41,780
Joined: Jan 13 2009
Gold: 25.20
May 28 2018 05:29pm
Quote (Blah58 @ May 28 2018 03:24pm)
And even if someone makes the most obviously politically charged movie ever, it still isn't political because you shouldn't take the actions or messages outside of the universe of film.

If a movie is 100% pro-life anti-abortion and spends the entire movie on that single subject, in term of its effect on our world...there is none because the values created for that works, that movie, don't matter outside of the movie.

This is the same reason violence in video games or movies doesn't actually matter. People who say violence in video games is creating killers are stupid. You literally have the same argument just on a different subject matter.


This.
Member
Posts: 66,871
Joined: Feb 24 2009
Gold: 250.00
Warn: 10%
May 28 2018 09:20pm
Quote (Kayeto @ May 28 2018 03:24pm)
Just you watch. 10 years from, the new hot meme that foreigners will have for us in addition to 'fat americans' is going to be 'gay americans'. It's already in the progress of happening.


I mean... that's kind of a stretch, don't you think lol? Especially when homosexuality is beginning to be so widely accepted in many countries, especially in Europe. It's still taboo in places like Russia and parts of Asia, but it's growing almost everywhere.


Quote (Kayeto @ May 28 2018 03:24pm)
I don't disagree with your claim that the development of alternative media (youtube and other social medias that allows people to connected worldwide without a studio being involved) has lessened the effect. The fact that we can agree that the free flow of ideas reduces the effect supports my claim that ideas were being restricted by the corporate content creators in the first place.


That's not what I was talking about at all.... Youtube and other "social media" outlets spread mostly half-truths, cherry-picked information or outright lies, the difference being that it's stupid people spreading lies as facts, vs intelligent people spreading lies as entertainment like with Television and Movies. I was directly speaking about the influx in factual information that's available around the world, and that people from other countries are now seeing us at our worst now vs just our movies and other propaganda efforts that tried to show us only in a positive light.

Quote (Kayeto @ May 28 2018 03:24pm)
I'm not saying the 60% should be marginalized. I'm saying I'd be less disappointed if they controlled only ~60% of the media that was released. Instead, their influence is greater. Sometimes the influence is direct (they buy up a big IP and inject their ideas directly into it). But often times it's more subtle, pressuring people who want to work in the industry to tow the line if they want to get picked for jobs.


That's not how capitalism works.... There are plenty of entities out there actively fighting against the "spread" of homosexuality, but when you're fighting against human-nature with fear based rhetoric, you should eventually lose out in the era of information. How long it's taking is just further evidence into the influence of false information being spread as fact.

Quote (Kayeto @ May 28 2018 03:24pm)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christianity_in_the_United_States : Christianity is the most adhered to religion in the United States, with 75% of polled American adults identifying themselves as Christian in 2015.

This is what happens when you try to make a christian movie: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2011/may/03/jim-caviezel-passion-of-the-christ

What you are saying about Gibson may be true, but does it apply also to Caviezel? I'm not saying that 75% of the movies have to have a Christian theme. Not by a long shot. But if someone has the budget and the means to produce the content, it deserves a fair shake on an open market. I'm disappointed that the liberal majority gets to discourage such productions because it conflicts with their ideas.


Every fucking person who gets blacklisted ends up with some excuse why it happened. Some of them may be true, but the majority of them are just fucking whiners who weren't good enough to make it. The truth is that with film, television, art and any other medium that works like this, is that there's a HUGE luck factor. Some people get lucky and if you're capable of making it over the hump and cementing yourself as a star, you can do w/e the fuck you want, and some people fizzle out and die before it even begins. There are plenty of successful republican/christian actors, directors, but once again, it is a field primarily dominated by Liberals, and if you've 80% liberals going to acting schools and auditioning for roles, you're going to have a disproportionate amount who make it in the business... That's just basic commonsense.

Quote (Kayeto @ May 28 2018 03:24pm)
If you honestly think that media didn't impact American acceptance of alternate sexuality, then I don't know what to tell you. Movies spread ideas and spreading ideas is one way to help more people understand them better. It contributes. It's not a clearcut situation of art driving culture OR art reacting to culture. It goes both ways, they both affect each other a little as the prevalent philosophy shifts. I can personally attest that I watched the movie But I'm a Cheerleader when I was 18 and it impacted my ability to understand what homosexuals had been dealing with. Otherwise, I would have had a harder time with the concept since I was a straight guy with no gay friends/family that I was close enough to actually have real talks with.


I don't think it makes as big of a difference as you seem to be claiming. The spread of acceptance has been a slow and gradual climb regardless of how supportive or "in-your-face" television and movies have been with the subject matter. It's like I said before, we're in the age of information and wanting to fuck everything is just animalistic nature. Dudes fucking dudes has been happening since the dawn of creation. People can hate it all they want because some fucking random book that copied and added to the Epic of Gilgamesh says it's wrong now, but that doesn't make it any less idiotic. If you're fighting against human nature/logic with "THIS BOOK SAYS NOT TO", you're going to lose out eventually, since all methods of control eventually stop working, and the bible/Christianity is just the latest/biggest control ploy to keep the masses in check.

I'm glad that it had an impact on you. I grew up in an a religious household, I spent 16-24 hours in church or doing church related activities a week, and my church was all fire and brimstone and anti-anything that wasn't 1950s acceptable. I was told I was going to hell for dying my hair by an elder once lol. I grew up starting in 2nd grade in a relatively small hick town where people flew confederate flags and I had beer cans thrown out of trucks at me when my hair dyed. Even in that close-minded of an environment and with no interactions with openly gay people (we had a couple in high-school WAYYYYY in the closet) I still knew that there was nothing wrong with it. I may not understand all the crazy shit coming out these days, and I think a lot of people are just seeking attention, but it's not my place to judge anyone and I think as long as both parties are consenting adults, you should be able to fuck whoever you want.


Quote (FroggyG @ May 28 2018 04:23pm)
What does that have to do with movies?



Tom Cruise is a Scientologist but that doesn't stop me from loving his movies.
You need to be able to separate your opinion of a person from your opinion of their work.

I don't care if a movie is made by a collaboration of Hitler, Stalin, Donald Trump, Satan, and the monster from IT.
If it's a good movie, I'll like the movie.


See, this guy gets it.

None of this shit matters, all that fucking matters is the end product.

I'll still watch any movie with Kevin Spacey because I think he's a phenomenal actor. Does that mean that I agree with his actions? Fuck no lol. That's not how shit works though. You being a terrible person, or a complete fucking idiot doesn't make me disrespect your ability to do your job well. Look at Clint Eastwood, after he gave that chair speech, it was clear the guy was a fucking retard when it came to politics without a single fucking coherent or truthful factoid in his head, but that doesn't mean I'm going to boycott his movies lol, the guy was a great actor and he's been a solid director (most recent movie aside). Another one, Tarantino, this guy is one of the biggest cunts in the world. I couldn't fathom trying to even have a conversation with him without losing my cool with how big of a pompous asshole I've heard he is. Does it make one fucking difference about how good his movies are? NOPE. They're still fucking amazing. People need to put their personal and petty bullshit aside, and if they can't, just stop watching movies and fuck off with your idiocy because all you're doing is wasting the time of everyone who understands how to separate reality and fiction.

This post was edited by jadeoshbogosh on May 28 2018 09:26pm
Member
Posts: 39,673
Joined: Jun 17 2006
Gold: 5,920.00
May 28 2018 09:39pm
Quote
and if you've 80% liberals going to acting schools and auditioning for roles, you're going to have a disproportionate amount who make it in the business... That's just basic commonsense.


Reminds me of that huge Oscar "controversy" a couple years ago where black people whined that people of colour are underrepresented in the Oscars because they had so few nominations. But then like... people with brains showed that proportionally everyone was represented equally. And then the next Oscar season was filled with poc as the institution fucking catered to the whiney bullshit rather than trying to attempt to appear to be a legitimate award based on actual talent.
Member
Posts: 16,229
Joined: May 28 2015
Gold: 2,118.35
May 29 2018 05:49am
Quote (Blah58 @ May 29 2018 01:39pm)
Reminds me of that huge Oscar "controversy" a couple years ago where black people whined that people of colour are underrepresented in the Oscars because they had so few nominations. But then like... people with brains showed that proportionally everyone was represented equally. And then the next Oscar season was filled with poc as the institution fucking catered to the whiney bullshit rather than trying to attempt to appear to be a legitimate award based on actual talent.


If I was black and won an award off the back of that I would seriously be considering if it was even deserved. Would be a total buzzkill if you didnt have your head up your ass
Member
Posts: 38,137
Joined: May 28 2006
Gold: 0.00
Member
Posts: 66,871
Joined: Feb 24 2009
Gold: 250.00
Warn: 10%
May 29 2018 11:45am
Made 110 mil of the projected 150 mil opening weekend....

"Are movies about white men box office poison" is possibly the dumbest fucking headline imaginable seeing as the main cast (and almost all of the side cast) of Infinity War was white....

Helical showing off his big brains again though.
Member
Posts: 38,137
Joined: May 28 2006
Gold: 0.00
May 29 2018 11:59am
Quote (jadeoshbogosh @ May 29 2018 07:45pm)
Helical showing off his big brains again though.


Go Back To Movies & TV Shows Topic List
Prev1101112131416Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll