d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Entertainment Room > Movies & TV Shows > American Horror Story Season 2
Prev12347Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 13,948
Joined: Nov 14 2007
Gold: 65.11
Nov 7 2012 12:16pm
Is this show any good?
May try it
Member
Posts: 47,890
Joined: Sep 15 2009
Gold: 4.21
Warn: 60%
Nov 7 2012 12:23pm
Quote (SlashMePlz @ Nov 7 2012 02:16pm)
Is this show any good?
May try it


Watch season 1. Season 2 isn't very good so far. Season 1 is great though.
Member
Posts: 14,211
Joined: Feb 15 2006
Gold: 53,816.00
Nov 7 2012 12:55pm
Quote (HeyMan @ Nov 7 2012 02:23pm)
Watch season 1. Season 2 isn't very good so far. Season 1 is great though.


season 1 is very different
but season 2 is just as good imo
in a different way, and i like it

but thats just me,
i prefer some substance over just gore, blood and horror -_-
Member
Posts: 47,890
Joined: Sep 15 2009
Gold: 4.21
Warn: 60%
Nov 7 2012 12:58pm
Quote (7high @ Nov 7 2012 02:55pm)
season 1 is very different
but season 2 is just as good imo
in a different way, and i like it

but thats just me,
i prefer some substance over just gore, blood and horror  -_-


What are you talking about? Season 2 has less substance and more gore/blood. Season 2 is no where near as good. Not one interesting thing has happened so far imo. There better be a huge twist soon or else this will be a huge let down. Season 1 was great and full of twists.
Member
Posts: 13,948
Joined: Nov 14 2007
Gold: 65.11
Nov 7 2012 01:54pm
Quote (HeyMan @ 7 Nov 2012 19:23)
Watch season 1. Season 2 isn't very good so far. Season 1 is great though.


Alright will do. Thanks
Member
Posts: 14,211
Joined: Feb 15 2006
Gold: 53,816.00
Nov 7 2012 02:33pm
Quote (HeyMan @ Nov 7 2012 02:58pm)
What are you talking about? Season 2 has less substance and more gore/blood. Season 2 is no where near as good. Not one interesting thing has happened so far imo. There better be a huge twist soon or else this will be a huge let down. Season 1 was great and full of twists.


u must like twizzlers B)
Member
Posts: 4,808
Joined: Mar 23 2006
Gold: 36.49
Nov 7 2012 03:36pm
Quote (7high @ Nov 6 2012 11:35pm)
I find it interesting that no one has mentioned a major difference in this season

at least to me, it seemed to be steeped in social commentary
maybe its just me

but the whole God vs Science is a big theme
and obv mental illness, humane treatment, etc

also the stigma of being falsely accused, IE the bloodyface kid, and the reporter who believed the lies
then changed her mind

it doesnt seem as "horror" centered as season 1
but i love the new direction,
again, thats just how i saw it

but its good to explore those topics, especially in the context of the 60's

thoughts?
anyone else notice this?


I think this season is fascinating because it revolves around the old school treatment of mental illness. Even though the show is dramatized, not long ago people were treated similarly (in a barbaric or religious oriented) way. If you actually look into the history of mental illness it's quite sickening and scary how people were treated... drilling into your skull, lobotomy (using an instrument like an icepick and hammering it through the top of the eye socket to pierce the brain and sever their emotion-controlling center to control violence), punishment, blood-letting, chaining them to walls where it's just tight enough that they have to sleep upright standing in their own excrement. People were treated like animals. Treatment nowadays is much more technologically advanced and humane.

And so it seems that part of the theme of this season is some of that realism. Another huge theme still current in mental illness is the stigma that it carries. When you are labelled as a person with a mental condition you carry it wherever you go. The saddest part is that I've been in the psych ward and a lot of the patients I wouldn't be able to pick off the street and say they have a problem until I really questioned them or saw their psych history. But if I told you they were schizophrenic you probably wouldn't want to approach them.

I like this season better than the first.

This post was edited by Hysteria on Nov 7 2012 03:38pm
Member
Posts: 47,890
Joined: Sep 15 2009
Gold: 4.21
Warn: 60%
Nov 7 2012 04:12pm
Quote (7high @ Nov 7 2012 04:33pm)
u must like twizzlers  B)


I love them.
Member
Posts: 14,211
Joined: Feb 15 2006
Gold: 53,816.00
Nov 7 2012 05:14pm
Quote (Hysteria @ Nov 7 2012 05:36pm)
I think this season is fascinating because it revolves around the old school treatment of mental illness. Even though the show is dramatized, not long ago people were treated similarly (in a barbaric or religious oriented) way. If you actually look into the history of mental illness it's quite sickening and scary how people were treated... drilling into your skull, lobotomy (using an instrument like an icepick and hammering it through the top of the eye socket to pierce the brain and sever their emotion-controlling center to control violence), punishment, blood-letting, chaining them to walls where it's just tight enough that they have to sleep upright standing in their own excrement. People were treated like animals. Treatment nowadays is much more technologically advanced and humane.

And so it seems that part of the theme of this season is some of that realism. Another huge theme still current in mental illness is the stigma that it carries. When you are labelled as a person with a mental condition you carry it wherever you go. The saddest part is that I've been in the psych ward and a lot of the patients I wouldn't be able to pick off the street and say they have a problem until I really questioned them or saw their psych history. But if I told you they were schizophrenic you probably wouldn't want to approach them.

I like this season better than the first.


great post, thanks!
glad im not the only one who picked up on this
totally agree with everything you said

along with the mental illness is the big issue of God vs Science clashing
which is a controversial topic to mix in with mental illness
Member
Posts: 4,808
Joined: Mar 23 2006
Gold: 36.49
Nov 7 2012 10:02pm
Quote (7high @ Nov 7 2012 11:14pm)
great post, thanks!
glad im not the only one who picked up on this
totally agree with everything you said

along with the mental illness is the big issue of God vs Science clashing
which is a controversial topic to mix in with mental illness


Looks like there might be a lobotomy in the upcoming episodes. I saw a hammer and spike in the preview.
Go Back To Movies & TV Shows Topic List
Prev12347Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll