d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Computers & IT > Computer Building > Good Gaming Desktop Build? > Suggestions
Prev1234Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 17,029
Joined: Mar 28 2010
Gold: 519.00
Warn: 50%
Nov 12 2011 11:28pm
Quote (memnoch_thedevil2003 @ Nov 13 2011 01:22am)
No offense, but that build is so full of fail. If I weren't drinking and about to get laid I'd show/tell you why...maybe in the morning if I remember...


quoted you so u remember tomorrow :p

This post was edited by charlyak on Nov 12 2011 11:36pm
Member
Posts: 33,618
Joined: Feb 26 2003
Gold: 1.00
Nov 13 2011 12:32pm
Quote (charlyak @ Nov 13 2011 12:28am)
quoted you so u remember tomorrow :p


First, as was pointed out, original build had 8 sticks of Ram. Fail #1.
Second, Antec 900. Fail #2
Third, P67. Fail #3
Fourth, 570KR model means 3 year warranty, when for the EXACT same price he could have got the AR model and have a lifetime warranty, Fail #4.
Fifth, he could have got 2x 6970's for Less money, means more performance and less power draw. Fail #5
Sixth, he picked a very low quality PSU. Fail #6
Seventh, he picked a very low power PSU for SLI 570's. Fail #7
Eighth, he picked a 2600K for Gaming. Fail #8
Ninth, he's paying over $100 for a 500GB HD. Fail #9
Tenth, he picked a CM V8, a sub par cooler with an above average price, a Hyper 212+ performs equally if not better and is half the price. Fail #10


Here's a build that runs laps around that one you posted (his original parts only on the first page is over $1700), for nearly $200 less. Has better everything. I chose the Gigabyte 690's just for a price reference since he did not pick the lifetime warrantied 570's...otherwise I would go with the XFX 6970's for a little more, and still be $150 less then his build.

















Member
Posts: 21,563
Joined: Aug 29 2003
Gold: 62,608.00
Nov 13 2011 03:33pm
Quote (memnoch_thedevil2003 @ Nov 13 2011 10:32am)
First, as was pointed out, original build had 8 sticks of Ram. Fail #1.
Second, Antec 900. Fail #2
Third, P67. Fail #3
Fourth, 570KR model means 3 year warranty, when for the EXACT same price he could have got the AR model and have a lifetime warranty, Fail #4.
Fifth, he could have got 2x 6970's for Less money, means more performance and less power draw. Fail #5
Sixth, he picked a very low quality PSU. Fail #6
Seventh, he picked a very low power PSU for SLI 570's. Fail #7
Eighth, he picked a 2600K for Gaming. Fail #8
Ninth, he's paying over $100 for a 500GB HD. Fail #9
Tenth, he picked a CM V8, a sub par cooler with an above average price, a Hyper 212+ performs equally if not better and is half the price. Fail #10


#1 Was already pointed out and fixed
#2 Personal preference, some people like the antec 900 case, and since he's the one paying for it, we can't really say much about his choice in cases.
#3 He isn't buying an ssd and has no plans to o/c so a p67 is fine. Although I did recommend a z68 as well for the graphics addition from the mobo, it's really up to him.
#4 Viable
#5 Again, personal preference. He ended up only getting 1 gpu, and the gtx 570 has higher benchmarks than the 6970.
#6 Was pointed out already, OP says he is looking into it.
#7 Was pointed out, OP says he will change it.
#8 2600K is fine for gaming... Not really sure what you mean by this point.
#9 HDD prices have doubled recently because the flooding in Thailand, prices wont be back down til 2012, so if he needs the HDD soon, he has to pay that price.
#10 Was pointed out already, but it's up to the OP to decide what cooler he wants.

Member
Posts: 21,631
Joined: Mar 15 2011
Gold: 6,062.01
Nov 13 2011 03:40pm
The PSU showed 80% efficiency at full load, so it is not horrid but can be beaten, and for a cooler, I would recommend a CM 212 Evo.
Member
Posts: 33,618
Joined: Feb 26 2003
Gold: 1.00
Nov 13 2011 04:17pm
Quote (mjm69 @ Nov 13 2011 04:33pm)
#1 Was already pointed out and fixed(Still got multiple sticks instead of a 2 stick kit, and could have done better)
#2 Personal preference, some people like the antec 900 case, and since he's the one paying for it, we can't really say much about his choice in cases.(All cases are subjective yes of course, but he's buying a dated case with newer tech, and is going to run into space issues and have less cable management etc etc..)
#3 He isn't buying an ssd and has no plans to o/c so a p67 is fine. Although I did recommend a z68 as well for the graphics addition from the mobo, it's really up to him.(He mentioned possibly oc'ng the CPU if it was possible, see page 2, and if he has no plans on it, then why even get a K series CPU? The SSD is because of current prices on HD's and to show it could fit in his budget easily)
#4 Viable
#5 Again, personal preference. He ended up only getting 1 gpu, and the gtx 570 has higher benchmarks than the 6970. (Yes personal preference, but still a 6970 would have been the better choice, the point of this was to show what he could have got had he posted for help first instead of blindly buying things)
#6 Was pointed out already, OP says he is looking into it.
#7 Was pointed out, OP says he will change it.
#8 2600K is fine for gaming... Not really sure what you mean by this point. (Not fine for gaming when almost every single benchmark has the 2500K beating the 2600K, and it's a $100 less. Plain and simple the i7 is meant for PS, video editing, encoding etc. and as an after thought to that gaming)
#9 HDD prices have doubled recently because the flooding in Thailand, prices wont be back down til 2012, so if he needs the HDD soon, he has to pay that price. (While prices for retail drives have doubled in price due to the flooding, you can still pick up a gently used one for quite cheap, for example see [H] Forums Real Life Section)
#10 Was pointed out already, but it's up to the OP to decide what cooler he wants.(Sure it is up to the OP for every single part in his Pc, doesn't mean it's still not fail, because it is.)




I know what was pointed out and semi fixed, but I was going by original post, even though there is still stuff wrong with his "fix". The point was to show how much better of a system he could have got with his money, if people would only post first before they randomly spend money and buy parts thinking they did good... - I added in some to your response above.
Member
Posts: 39,748
Joined: Feb 17 2010
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 60%
Nov 13 2011 04:22pm
Quote (memnoch_thedevil2003 @ Nov 13 2011 05:17pm)
I know what was pointed out and semi fixed, but I was going by original post, even though there is still stuff wrong with his "fix". The point was to show how much better of a system he could have got with his money, if people would only post first before they randomly spend money and buy parts thinking they did good... - I added in some to your response above.


inb4anotherDidIdoOkay?thread
Member
Posts: 21,563
Joined: Aug 29 2003
Gold: 62,608.00
Nov 13 2011 05:28pm
Quote (memnoch_thedevil2003 @ Nov 13 2011 02:17pm)
I know what was pointed out and semi fixed, but I was going by original post, even though there is still stuff wrong with his "fix". The point was to show how much better of a system he could have got with his money, if people would only post first before they randomly spend money and buy parts thinking they did good...  - I added in some to your response above.


#1 Agree
#2 Agree
#3 I suggested to him that he o/c his cpu because he is paying more for the k series (even if he chose not to o/c, the k series does have higher benchmarks stock), but the z68 is mostly for o/cing gpu's AFAIK
#5 6970 being the better choice is debatable. Although I do agree with you, as in I would have chosen the 6970 over the gtx 570, but it's really up to what the buyer prefers.
#8 Not that I don't believe you, but which site are those benchmarks on? I completely agree with you that the i5 2500k is the Best Deal when it comes to gaming cpu's, but the i7 2600k is just as good. The benchmarks I have seen (pass mark) show the i5 and the i7 being on par in terms of gaming benchmarks, with the i7 beating out the i5 in terms of video editing, PS, etc. I don't know if he is only using his comp for gaming, because if he was, the i5 would definitely be the better choice in terms of value, but i7 is just as good (if you don't mind paying an extra $100).
#9 I agree a gently used HDD is the way to go, but this guy doesn't seem to care too much about price.
#10 Well it's overpriced for it's performance, but it gets the job done
Member
Posts: 12,516
Joined: Mar 22 2007
Gold: 8,069.50
Nov 13 2011 09:03pm
This post is a violation of the site rules and appropriate action was taken.

Quote (L4d @ Nov 12 2011 06:57pm)
It seems decent for Photoshop, but more RAM would be warranted, then.


What the actual fucks does this have to do with anything? This is the kind of completely useless shit that says all you're trying to do is increase your post count.


Quote (SaintValentine @ Nov 12 2011 07:56pm)
i got suspended for this. cry more L4d you tell the guy that 8 dimms of ram isn't enough. and then report me for calling you useless. I stand by it, you should NOT be allowed to post in these forums.


Everyone in this subforum seems to be pulling this kind of shit. Actually not even just in CHD, reports and suspensions are ridiculous everywhere now. I remember when it had to be something pretty douchey to get a suspension for it. Now it's like 50x easier than getting warn. I generally don't even notice my suspensions because they're over before I get back. I think I've only even been affected by it once or twice.

tl;dr People need to stop being crybaby pussies and mods needs to quit being power-hungry assholes.

Rabble rabble rabble...

This post was edited by Masta_B on Nov 13 2011 09:10pm
Member
Posts: 21,631
Joined: Mar 15 2011
Gold: 6,062.01
Nov 13 2011 10:08pm
At Master B, I was stating that the i7-2600k and 570 are good for Photoshop, but the OP wanted to play games, so a conclusion should have been drawn that those components could have been changed; I will admit that the stating of adding RAM was unnecessary because that was more of a joke...
Member
Posts: 19,472
Joined: Jun 20 2010
Gold: 310.01
Nov 14 2011 01:57am
Quote (L4d @ Nov 13 2011 10:08pm)
At Master B, I was stating that the i7-2600k and 570 are good for Photoshop, but the OP wanted to play games, so a conclusion should have been drawn that those components could have been changed; I will admit that the stating of adding RAM was unnecessary because that was more of a joke...


only joke here is you.
Go Back To Computer Building Topic List
Prev1234Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll