d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Computers & IT > Computer Building > Graphics Card Suggestion > Radeon Pro 580x Vs Vega 48
12Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 7,171
Joined: Mar 31 2016
Gold: 69,820.74
Mar 19 2019 06:26pm
I am buying my first iMac and I want to buy a very high iMac.

I dont think I will play games, but I am a drone photographer and my current decent drone already has 4k videos. I don't know how soon 8k is going to become a common thing.
I plan to have the iMac for several years, at least 8-10 years, so I don't want the iMac to be outdated soon.

So the top end iMac comes with Radeon Pro 580X with 8GB GDDR5 memory
There is an upgrade to Radeon Pro Vega 48 with 8GB HBM2 memory for $450

I've never heard of HBM2.
How much better is the latter than the former? Is the former one going to suffice my needs 6-8 years down the line?

Any insight is appreciated <3
"Dont buy" posts are not welcome
Member
Posts: 109,874
Joined: Feb 1 2006
Gold: 10,152.00
Mar 19 2019 07:13pm
you pc will be dated in 3 years, 5 if your lucky, no matter what you buy.
a 580atm is imo a mid / mid-low range gpu at best.
Also don't buy.
Member
Posts: 7,171
Joined: Mar 31 2016
Gold: 69,820.74
Mar 19 2019 07:50pm
Quote (King Atrhur @ Mar 19 2019 08:13pm)
you pc will be dated in 3 years, 5 if your lucky, no matter what you buy.
a 580atm is imo a mid / mid-low range gpu at best.
Also don't buy.


why not to buy?
How much better is Vega 48 compared to 580?
Member
Posts: 109,874
Joined: Feb 1 2006
Gold: 10,152.00
Mar 19 2019 07:56pm
cause you said not to say it.

Member
Posts: 7,171
Joined: Mar 31 2016
Gold: 69,820.74
Mar 19 2019 07:59pm
Quote (King Atrhur @ Mar 19 2019 08:56pm)
cause you said not to say it.


lol.
Any idea on the comparison of the GPUs I mentioned?
And the amount of GPU I would need?
I am not a hardcore photographer yet. Just doing as a hobby
Member
Posts: 109,874
Joined: Feb 1 2006
Gold: 10,152.00
Mar 19 2019 08:17pm
Quote (kingmaker @ Mar 19 2019 08:59pm)
lol.
Any idea on the comparison of the GPUs I mentioned?
And the amount of GPU I would need?
I am not a hardcore photographer yet. Just doing as a hobby


idk tbh, the desktop variant is a vega 56 and its only 50% better.
So its less then a 1070 but more then a 1060.
I also have no idea how much the upgrade would cost either.
But if its over 1-200 imo it's a total waste.

This better % I'm throwing out is strictly for gaming, neither imo will help much for photo editing.
Buy w/e's cheaper save rest for the inevitable upgrade.
Member
Posts: 7,171
Joined: Mar 31 2016
Gold: 69,820.74
Mar 19 2019 08:39pm
Quote (King Atrhur @ Mar 19 2019 09:17pm)
idk tbh, the desktop variant is a vega 56 and its only 50% better.
So its less then a 1070 but more then a 1060.
I also have no idea how much the upgrade would cost either.
But if its over 1-200 imo it's a total waste.

This better % I'm throwing out is strictly for gaming, neither imo will help much for photo editing.
Buy w/e's cheaper save rest for the inevitable upgrade.


yeah the upgrade costs $450 and I also do video editing.
But yeah inevitable upgrades are processor and RAM
Member
Posts: 16,909
Joined: Aug 14 2009
Gold: 0.00
Mar 19 2019 08:59pm
You got a while before 8k is mainstream.
Member
Posts: 7,171
Joined: Mar 31 2016
Gold: 69,820.74
Mar 20 2019 06:28am
Quote (zell1luk @ Mar 19 2019 09:59pm)
You got a while before 8k is mainstream.


So I have actually decided to go with the 580X graphics since I do not have a necessity for high graphics right now. And if in any case I need more graphics 5 years later, I can buy an eGPU?
What do you think?
Member
Posts: 16,909
Joined: Aug 14 2009
Gold: 0.00
Mar 20 2019 11:28am
Quote (kingmaker @ Mar 20 2019 06:28am)
So I have actually decided to go with the 580X graphics since I do not have a necessity for high graphics right now. And if in any case I need more graphics 5 years later, I can buy an eGPU?
What do you think?


In 5 years your macbook will be broken and you can just build a desktop.
Go Back To Computer Building Topic List
12Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll