Quote (Voyaging @ 16 Dec 2011 21:40)
I think if you aren't born with a good voice you just won't sing well.
Look at American Idol, they all fucking suck. Carbon copies of each other.
If you ARE born with a good voice, lessons can be somewhat helpful, though not that important.
Typical words from an inexperienced person. Ask all professional singers and you will hear that anyone can learn to sing well. It's just that it isn't enough sometimes to just sing 'well' if you want to be a known singer (all these people who sing 'well' will AT LEAST make it through the first auditions of American Idol, just to give you an idea). You need a distinctive voice, a voice they recognize immediately on the radio to make it to the top. Anyone can have a singing career if their devotion is enough. Even IF your singing isn't that great (hear some famous singers sing live and you know what I mean), you still can make it sound good these days in the studio, then the only thing you will need is good songwriting skills and/or commercial image building.
It isn't about being born with a good voice. It is about being born with good ears*. You learn how to sing through imitating, just like how you learn to talk. Anyone who can talk can learn to sing well. People who fail at the start on American Idol are mostly people who don't know much about music, or let's just say they're stupid (either they're too stupid to know that they're not good enough
yet to enter the competition or they're tone-deaf**). If you think singing is JUST about hitting the right notes, you're (SO) wrong. Singing is telling a story, musically, and the most important thing is being able to connect emotionally with the audience. You CAN learn those things. It's the little things that distinguish the greatest from the good. Passion is also something you need. You can have a pleasant sounding, unique voice and you can have good ears*, but if you don't have enough interest in music or singing, you will not learn as quick as a person who is crazy about it and has ears* that have some problems with identifying notes at the beginning. I'm not going into details of course, because that would be wasted on people like you. People who lack interest in singing or the will to improve at it, people who like to talk and discuss about things they know little of and people who discourage others to become better just because they haven't succeeded themselves.
* With good ears, I mean that they have a well-developed auditory cortex (region of the brain that is responsible for the processing of sound information). You can't hear by JUST having ears of course.
** For the dumb / ignorant people: tone-deaf does not mean being deaf.
Quote (Darkshade @ 16 Dec 2011 23:03)
Bullshit.
Vocal chords are an instrument, and just like any instruments, practice makes the difference.
this