d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Entertainment Room > Favorite Songs & Bands > Hardcore/metal/experimental/metalcore Radio > So On And So Forth
Prev15678922Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 887
Joined: Oct 17 2010
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Warn: 10%
Dec 4 2011 07:14am
Quote (TAYLORfest @ Dec 4 2011 03:07pm)
Welcome to branching genres.
zzzz


i actually like most of the branches hardcore has had. as my username suggests, early emo/screamo, crust, powerviolence, grindcore, thrash etc. but metalcore and pretty much everything posted in this topic goes completely against all the basic hardcore principles as they once were, its ridiculous and a little sad. HC should be about DIY, standing up for shit, raw emotion and power, not triggered drumkits, overcompressed plastic guitarsounds, $10,000 studioproductions, a bunch of pseudo-technical idiots who think its a requirement for each hardcore song to have 5 breakdowns and singers who have this little competition of who is the biggest tough guy and who can kick in your teeth better.
Member
Posts: 14,423
Joined: Jul 12 2007
Gold: 150.32
Dec 4 2011 07:33am
Quote (SkRaMz @ Dec 4 2011 07:14am)
i actually like most of the branches hardcore has had. as my username suggests, early emo/screamo, crust, powerviolence, grindcore, thrash etc. but metalcore and pretty much everything posted in this topic goes completely against all the basic hardcore principles as they once were, its ridiculous and a little sad. HC should be about DIY, standing up for shit, raw emotion and power, not triggered drumkits, overcompressed plastic guitarsounds, $10,000 studioproductions, a bunch of pseudo-technical idiots who think its a requirement for each hardcore song to have 5 breakdowns and singers who have this little competition of who is the biggest tough guy and who can kick in your teeth better.


Since when did any particular genre of music have to hold loyalties to the foundation?
Isn't the entire point of being a different genre to be different than the predecessors?
Different music style, lyric composition, and social group?
Similarities persist indeed, but that does not mean that every song has to be about sad kids being beat up or the government breaking you down.
I understand the statement above is a terrible generalization of the genres you listed, but it was to illustrate a point.

In the end, the music is meant to be the way it is.
If you don't like it, then don't listen to it.
I enjoy many genres.
The ones I don't enjoy, I don't listen to.
Member
Posts: 887
Joined: Oct 17 2010
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Warn: 10%
Dec 4 2011 07:47am
Quote (TAYLORfest @ Dec 4 2011 03:33pm)
Since when did any particular genre of music have to hold loyalties to the foundation?
Isn't the entire point of being a different genre to be different than the predecessors?
Different music style, lyric composition, and social group?
Similarities persist indeed, but that does not mean that every song has to be about sad kids being beat up or the government breaking you down.
I understand the statement above is a terrible generalization of the genres you listed, but it was to illustrate a point.

In the end, the music is meant to be the way it is.
If you don't like it, then don't listen to it.
I enjoy many genres.
The ones I don't enjoy, I don't listen to.


oh i agree, and i dont have a problem with metalcore or the people who listen to it, its just that these people still keep yelling that its hardcore when really its not hardcore and thats a little frustrating, but maybe im just a whiny kid
Member
Posts: 14,423
Joined: Jul 12 2007
Gold: 150.32
Dec 4 2011 08:11am
Quote (SkRaMz @ Dec 4 2011 07:47am)
oh i agree, and i dont have a problem with metalcore or the people who listen to it, its just that these people still keep yelling that its hardcore when really its not hardcore and thats a little frustrating, but maybe im just a whiny kid


Hardcore has really just become a general term for all the included genres.
Member
Posts: 43,119
Joined: Sep 13 2007
Gold: 111.00
Dec 4 2011 11:54am
Quote (TAYLORfest @ Dec 4 2011 09:11am)
Hardcore has really just become a general term for all the included genres.


This.
Member
Posts: 43,119
Joined: Sep 13 2007
Gold: 111.00
Dec 4 2011 02:43pm
This doesn't quite fall under this category, well kinda. but it's one of the greatest thing's i have ever heard. Must Listen

Member
Posts: 14,423
Joined: Jul 12 2007
Gold: 150.32
Dec 4 2011 03:07pm
Quote (00apacolypse @ Dec 4 2011 02:43pm)
This doesn't quite fall under this category, well kinda. but it's one of the greatest thing's i have ever heard. Must Listen

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dJwNfRaPp08


Not bad. :thumbsup:
Member
Posts: 1,676
Joined: Jul 10 2011
Gold: 0.00
Dec 4 2011 04:19pm
[QUOTE=TAYLORfest,Dec 4 2011 04:26am]When is Kesha good?
When Monsters Scare You! cover her garbage.

great song i enjoy it

This post was edited by LongCut on Dec 4 2011 04:20pm
Member
Posts: 1,676
Joined: Jul 10 2011
Gold: 0.00
Dec 4 2011 04:20pm
Quote (TAYLORfest @ Dec 4 2011 03:07pm)
Not bad.  :thumbsup:


what he said
Member
Posts: 43,119
Joined: Sep 13 2007
Gold: 111.00
Dec 7 2011 01:10am
My buddies band, decent
Go Back To Favorite Songs & Bands Topic List
Prev15678922Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll