d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Entertainment Room > Favorite Songs & Bands > D2jsp's Official Hardcore Thread #4
Prev1145146147148149210Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 2,733
Joined: Nov 5 2008
Gold: 0.00
Feb 25 2010 03:59pm
Quote (HookedOnLSD @ Feb 25 2010 05:56pm)
oh god carnifex is playing? christ....


i just dislike all those bands. i dont know why, just dont appeal to me. and im leaving april 7th. my last show in texas for what i know is going to be my birthday, april 2nd. driving to lubbock for trapped under ice.


yo hooked, in your opinion why do you claim most deathcore/grindcore bands "generic"? not starting an argument. im just curious.
Member
Posts: 22,360
Joined: Feb 20 2008
Gold: 600.69
Warn: 100%
Feb 25 2010 04:12pm
Quote (xXCooReetXx @ Feb 25 2010 01:59pm)
yo hooked, in your opinion why do you claim most deathcore/grindcore bands "generic"? not starting an argument. im just curious.


because they are generic

listen to whitechapel/carnifex/winds of plague whoever you wanna fill in there

if they all tuned the same and you took out the vocals there would be no way to tell them apart


edit: grindcore is different but I doubt any of you listen to grindcore anyways so nn to comment about it

This post was edited by Monster666 on Feb 25 2010 04:12pm
Member
Posts: 2,733
Joined: Nov 5 2008
Gold: 0.00
Feb 25 2010 04:13pm
Quote (Monster666 @ Feb 25 2010 10:12pm)
because they are generic

listen to whitechapel/carnifex/winds of plague whoever you wanna fill in there

if they all tuned the same and you took out the vocals there would be no way to tell them apart


thanks for your input.
Member
Posts: 22,360
Joined: Feb 20 2008
Gold: 600.69
Warn: 100%
Feb 25 2010 04:15pm
Quote (xXCooReetXx @ Feb 25 2010 02:13pm)
thanks for your input.


why do you think they aren't generic since we are on the topic I would be interested to see what parts within the deathcore bands you think are unique
Member
Posts: 2,733
Joined: Nov 5 2008
Gold: 0.00
Feb 25 2010 04:16pm
Quote (Monster666 @ Feb 25 2010 10:15pm)
why do you think they aren't generic since we are on the topic I would be interested to see what parts within the deathcore bands you think are unique


no no, i never really had an exact definition on why bands are generic. oh fuck yeah most of them are all the same.(sound wise) but for some reason i think veil of maya, despised icon, chelsea grin, etc(ones i listen to) all stand out to me imo. thats why i asked about neing "generic" never really understood why. just went with it.
Member
Posts: 27,711
Joined: May 26 2006
Gold: 454.00
Feb 25 2010 04:19pm
Quote (xXCooReetXx @ Feb 25 2010 03:59pm)
yo hooked, in your opinion why do you claim most deathcore/grindcore bands "generic"? not starting an argument. im just curious.


because everyone is going for the same sound it seems like.

high pitch scream --> bree --> grunt --> breakdown for 3 minutes --> go back to singing about raping a girl and cutting their organs out.
i will admit to enjoying a bit of deathcore live about 3 years ago, but i grew up since then. plus i cant stand scene kids.


i was never big into grindcore. i like pig destroyer but that is about it
Member
Posts: 22,360
Joined: Feb 20 2008
Gold: 600.69
Warn: 100%
Feb 25 2010 04:20pm
Quote (xXCooReetXx @ Feb 25 2010 02:16pm)
no no, i never really had an exact definition on why bands are generic. oh fuck yeah most of them are all the same.(sound wise) but for some reason i think veil of maya, despised icon, chelsea grin, etc(ones i listen to) all stand out to me imo. thats why i asked about neing "generic" never really understood why. just went with it.


Veil of Maya just try way too hard to be meta but can't play at all imo

Despised Icon isn't deathcore at all I would say they are just hardcore with the worlds worst pig squeals

but yes I suppose those 2 do have a semi distinct sound to them (never listened to Chelsea Grin for more than 5 minutes so no opinion there) but the style of their music is still very generic

their lyrical content, tuning, and breakdowns are pretty much the same across the board which makes listening to the music get really old really fast which is my main problem with hardcore/deathcore

I could listen to Despised Icon for about a song then the next song comes on and sounds exactly the same so it just gets old fast, plus breakdowns kill music for me nothing screams I have no idea how to play the guitar quite like a breakdown does
Member
Posts: 22,360
Joined: Feb 20 2008
Gold: 600.69
Warn: 100%
Feb 25 2010 04:21pm
Quote (HookedOnLSD @ Feb 25 2010 02:19pm)
because everyone is going for the same sound it seems like.

high pitch scream --> bree --> grunt --> breakdown for 3 minutes --> go back to singing about raping a girl and cutting their organs out.
i will admit to enjoying a bit of deathcore live about 3 years ago, but i grew up since then. plus i cant stand scene kids.


i was never big into grindcore. i like pig destroyer but that is about it


good band

real grindcore is like real black metal, its cool for about 5 minutes then you realize they take it seriously and just laugh at them

Member
Posts: 27,711
Joined: May 26 2006
Gold: 454.00
Feb 25 2010 04:24pm
Quote (Monster666 @ Feb 25 2010 04:20pm)
Veil of Maya just try way too hard to be meta but can't play at all imo

Despised Icon isn't deathcore at all I would say they are just hardcore with the worlds worst pig squeals

but yes I suppose those 2 do have a semi distinct sound to them (never listened to Chelsea Grin for more than 5 minutes so no opinion there) but the style of their music is still very generic

their lyrical content, tuning, and breakdowns are pretty much the same across the board which makes listening to the music get really old really fast which is my main problem with hardcore/deathcore

I could listen to Despised Icon for about a song then the next song comes on and sounds exactly the same so it just gets old fast, plus breakdowns kill music for me nothing screams I have no idea how to play the guitar quite like a breakdown does


veil of maya is probably the best "deathcore" band though.

despised icon is deathcore as can get. chelsea grin is fucking lame scene kids.
Member
Posts: 27,711
Joined: May 26 2006
Gold: 454.00
Feb 25 2010 04:27pm
i have no speakers so im not sure if this is good quality or not.


Alfa & Omega got added onto sxsw.

Go Back To Favorite Songs & Bands Topic List
Prev1145146147148149210Next
Closed New Topic New Poll